![]() |
|
Exposing the Dark Forces Behind the Snowden Smears - Printable Version +- Deep Politics Forum (https://deeppoliticsforum.com/fora) +-- Forum: Deep Politics Forum (https://deeppoliticsforum.com/fora/forum-1.html) +--- Forum: Applied Linguistics, Cognitive Science, and Framing the Discourse (https://deeppoliticsforum.com/fora/forum-35.html) +--- Thread: Exposing the Dark Forces Behind the Snowden Smears (/thread-10973.html) |
Exposing the Dark Forces Behind the Snowden Smears - Peter Lemkin - 05-11-2013 Clarifying Snowden's Freedom' By Ray McGovernNovember 3, 2013A common angle from the mainstream U.S. media is that NSA leaker Edward Snowden will regret his asylum in Russia (rather than life in prison in the U.S.). A quote from ex-CIA analyst Ray McGovern was used in support of that theme, but he has asked the New York Times to clarify it. By Ray McGovern (addressing the New York Times editors) I was quoted in Steven Lee Myers's "In Shadows, Hints of a Life and Even a Job for Snowden," published by the New York Times on Oct. 31, as saying (about former National Security Agency contractor Edward Snowden), "He's free, but not completely free" in asylum in Russia. An unfortunate juxtaposition in the text of Mr. Myers's piece has led several acquaintances to misinterpret my words. I trust you will agree that the issue is of some importance; thus, my request that you publish this clarification. NSA whistleblower Edward Snowden speaking in Moscow on Oct. 9, 2013, after receiving an award from an organization of former U.S. intelligence officials. (From a video posted by WikiLeaks)Mr. Myers quotes me correctly. Unfortunately, the immediately preceding sentences quote a Russian journalist, who "cautioned" that the appearance of a "happy, open asylum" could be "propaganda," and that the Russian security services might be waiting to question Mr. Snowden until he becomes "increasingly dependent on them." This is not at all what I meant by "not completely free." For starters, I guess I'm not sure how free you can feel being stateless, the State Department having revoked your passport. Still more on this issue emerged on Oct. 9, after Mr. Snowden was presented with this year's Sam Adams Associates Award for Integrity in Intelligence. We four Sam Adams Associates Jesselyn Radack, Thomas Drake, Coleen Rowley, and I chatted into the wee hours with Mr. Snowden and WikiLeaks journalist Ms. Sarah Harrison. (It was Ms. Harrison who facilitated his departure from Hong Kong on June 23. She has been at his side ever since to witness that he is not undergoing at the hands of the Russians what in some Western countries are called "enhanced interrogation techniques.") I asked Mr. Snowden whether he was aware that just six days before our Sam Adams award ceremony, Michael Hayden, former director of both the NSA and the CIA had said publicly that he had "thought of nominating Mr. Snowden … for a different list" an unmistakable hint that Mr. Snowden be put on President Barack Obama's infamous "Kill List." With a wan smile, Mr. Snowden assured me that Yes; he keeps well up on such things. And did he know that Mike Rogers, chair of the House Intelligence Committee, chimed right in with immediate support for Hayden's suggestion, stating, "I can help you with that?" This time the wan smile gave way to a wince and another Yes. (Both Hayden and Rogers were speaking at an Oct. 3 conference sponsored by the Washington Post, which, oddly, neglected to report on this macabre/mafiatype pas de deux.) After the back-to-back wan smile and wince, I resisted the urge to ask Mr. Snowden if he saw reassurance in the official letter of July 23 from U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder to his Russian counterpart conveying Holder's promise: "Mr. Snowden will not be tortured … if he returns to the United States." In his Oct. 31 article, Mr. Myers includes an instructive remark from Anatoly Kucherena, a Russian lawyer assisting Mr. Snowden. Mr. Kucherena told Myers he would not discuss Mr. Snowden's life in exile "because the level of threat from the U.S. government structures is still very high." THAT'S what I meant by "not completely free." Exposing the Dark Forces Behind the Snowden Smears - Peter Lemkin - 05-11-2013 (CNN) -- Leaked classified documents show the U.S. National Security Agency and its British counterpart are among the "worst offenders" of mass surveillance without oversight, according to an open letter purportedly written by Edward Snowden and published Sunday by the German magazine Der Spiegel. The publication of the letter, titled "A Manifesto for the Truth," comes as leaks by the former NSA contract analyst have roiled U.S.-European relations amid allegations that the NSA and the UK's Government Communications Headquarters monitored the communication data of some world leaders. "The world has learned a lot in a short amount of time about irresponsibly operated security agencies and, at times, criminal surveillance programs. Sometimes the agencies try to avoid controls," Snowden wrote, according to the news magazine. "While the NSA and GCHQ (the British national security agency) appear to be the worst offenders -- at least according to the documents that are currently public -- we cannot forget that mass surveillance is a global problem and needs a global solution." Edward Snowden: I'm no criminal Might Snowden testify in Germany, U.S.? Edward Snowden's new job Glenn Greenwald on NSA spying on alliesThe letter, published in German by Der Spiegel, was written on Friday in Moscow and provided to Der Spiegel through a "locked channel," the news magazine said. It was published in German and has been translated by CNN. Snowden, 30, has admitted in interviews he was the source behind the leak of classified NSA documents, which revealed the existence of top-secret surveillance programs that collect records of domestic e-mails and telephone calls in the United States and monitor the cell phone and Internet activity of overseas residents. He is wanted in the United States on espionage charges. A recent report by Der Spiegel, citing documents provided by Snowden, alleged the NSA monitored German Chancellor Angela Merkel's cell phone. Some reports also suggest the United States carried out surveillance on French and Spanish citizens. The allegations have prompted some European countries to call for investigations. It also has prompted congressional hearings in the United States, where some are calling for more transparency and more oversight of American spy programs. Opinion: Don't underestimate risks of government spying 'Witch hunt' The letter also accused governments of trying to squash debate about mass surveillance "with a never before seen witch hunt" that threatens journalists and criminalizes the publication of details about the programs. In the letter, Snowden purportedly writes that his actions were bringing about change. "The debate they wanted to avoid is now taking place in countries around the world," the letter said. "And instead of causing damage, the use of this new public knowledge is causing society to push for political reforms, oversight and new laws." Snowden has been in Moscow since June after fleeing from Hong Kong. In August, Russia granted him asylum for one year. Snowden gets website job in Russia The release of the open letter is the second in a matter of days from Snowden, who released a letter to German authorities through an intermediary. Last week, Hans-Christian Stroebele, a member of Germany's parliament, met with Snowden in Russia. Stroebele returned from the meeting with a letter from Snowden to German authorities, which was distributed to the media. In it, Snowden said he is confident that with international support, the United States would abandon its efforts to "treat dissent as defection" and "criminalize political speech with felony charges." "I hope that when the difficulties of this humanitarian situation have been resolved, I will be able to cooperate in the responsible finding of fact regarding reports in the media, particularly in regard to the truth and authenticity of documents, as appropriate and in accordance with the law," he wrote. Report: Snowden's Russia asylum not breached by NSA spying reports 'Face justice' The White House did not immediately respond to Snowden's claims in the letter. But earlier Sunday, White House Senior Adviser Dan Pfeiffer said on ABC's "This Week" that there has been no discussion of granting Snowden clemency. "Mr. Snowden violated U.S. law," Pfeiffer said. "And our belief has always been that he should return to the U.S. and face justice." It was a sentiment echoed by the heads of the House and Senate intelligence committees. "He had an opportunity -- if what he was, was a whistle-blower -- to pick up the phone and call the House Intelligence Committee, the Senate Intelligence Committee, and say, 'I have some information,'" Sen. Dianne Feinstein, chairwoman of the Senate Intelligence Committee, said Sunday on CBS' "Face the Nation." House Intelligence Committee Chairman Mike Rogers, R-Michigan, said Snowden has to "own up with what he's done." "If he wants to come back and open up to the responsibility of the fact that he took and stole information, he violated his oath, he disclosed classified information -- that by the way has allowed three different terrorist organizations, affiliates of al Qaeda to change the way they communicate -- I'd be happy to have that discussion with him," Rogers said on "Face the Nation." Exposing the Dark Forces Behind the Snowden Smears - Peter Lemkin - 15-11-2013 Military & Defense More: Edward Snowden It's Now Clear That Edward Snowden's Life Is Dictated By Russian IntelligenceMichael Kelley Nov. 1, 2013, 10:00 AM 18,308 REUTERSEdward Snowden is seen in front of the Christ the Saviour Cathedral in central Moscow. Even as Edward Snowden's disclosures of U.S. spying continue to create global waves, it's becoming clear that the American's life is supervised by Russian intelligence agents."He's actually surrounded by these people," Andrei Soldatov, an investigative journalist who co-authored a history of the Russia's Federal Security Service (FSB), told Steven Lee Meyers of The New York Times. That has appeared to be the case since the 30-year-old arrived in Moscow from Hong Kong on June 23, when a radio host in Moscow "saw about 20 Russian officials, supposedly FSB agents, in suits, crowding around somebody in a restricted area of the airport," according to Anna Nemtsova of Foreign Policy. "When the F.S.B. actually got him, they started to handle it their own way," Soldatov told The Times. "This is the way the security services operate all the time." Ray McGovern, a former CIA officer who presented Snowden with a whistleblowing award and visited his apartment last month, said he had to pass through metal detectors before the meeting and that the former CIA technician appeared to be attended by some kind of official Russian security detail. Snowden's life in Russia has been overseen by Anatoly Kucherena, a lawyer employed by the FSB, as well as Sarah Harrison, a WikiLeaks advisor who has reportedly been by Snowden's side since he was in China. A Kremlin-linked news agency has posted pictures of Snowden grocery shopping and riding a boat, and Kucherena says that Snowden got a job at an unnamed Russian website. Soldatov and others cautioned to the Times that what the FSB allows for public consumption may present an impression of a happy and free asylum while obscuring ulterior motives for hosting the former CIA technician and NSA-trained hacker. From Meyer's report in the Times: The security services now protecting Mr. Snowden, [Soldatov] said, might not even try to question him soon on what he knows perhaps the greatest worry of American officials but rather simply let him live in such circumstances and become increasingly dependent on them. In August WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange claimed that the FSB hasn't even interviewed Snowden, but that almost certainly false. Lingering questionsThe unusual circumstances raise two significant questions. The first involves what the Russians can potentially glean from Snowden; the second involves the role of WikiLeaks.In October he told the Times that "a zero percent chance the Russians or Chinese have received any documents," referring to the stolen trove of classified NSA documents that he took from Hawaii to Hong Kong. The information includes not only the "blueprints of the NSA" but also 30,000 documents that do "not deal with NSA surveillance but primarily with standard intelligence about other countries' military capabilities, including weapons systems," according to a report in the Washington Post. Snowden claimed to the Times that he gave all of the classified documents to journalists he met in Hong Kong, but there are several holes in that assertion. One of those journalists, Glenn Greenwald, has said that he believes Snowden held back some documents, saying Snowden "was clear he did not want to give to journalists things he did not think should be published." And following Snowden outing himself on June 9 and subsequently parting with the journalists, he leaked specific IP addresses in China and Hong Kong the NSA was hacking to the South China Morning Post. He also told SCMP: "If I have time to go through this information, I would like to make it available to journalists in each country to make their own assessment." No matter how all of the documents left his possession in Hong Kong, Snowden's ability to pull off the leak of the century means he has an enormous amount of highly valuable information in his head. "Snowden understood exactly how far he could push [the NSA]," Robert Caruso, a former assistant command security manager in the Navy and consultant, told Business Insider in July. "That, coupled with his successful exploitation of our entire vetting process, makes him very dangerous." Caruso refused to discuss Snowden's actions after Hawaii but did say that Snowden "understands how to exploit our systems human systems, vetting systems, and accountability systems." WikiLeaks met with Snowden in Hong Kong after he went underground and facilitated his arrival in Moscow. The organization has clearly been coordinating with the FSB since Harrison is by Snowden's side, the FSB surrounds him, and WikiLeaks arranged for four former U.S. government officials to present him with a whistleblower award in Moscow. Despite those uncertainties, Snowden's father told the Times that he knew very little about his son's life in Russia and declined to detail what he did know, saying that the "story isn't really about him at this point." The story of the recognized NSA overreach that Snowden's leaks have exposed certainly is not but his vulnerability after landing in the hands of the Kremlin is a reason to worry. SEE ALSO: Edward Snowden's Claim About Ditching All Of His Secret Documents Doesn't Add Up Read more: http://www.businessinsider.com/snowden-is-supervised-by-russian-intelligence-2013-11#ixzz2khCg4hJv Exposing the Dark Forces Behind the Snowden Smears - Peter Lemkin - 16-11-2013 NSA chief says Edward Snowden has shared up to 200,000 classified documents with media and that leaks increase the probability of a terrorist attackBy Reuters Reporter and Daily Mail ReporterPUBLISHED:20:51 GMT, 15 November 2013| UPDATED:22:12 GMT, 15 November 2013 Former NSA contractor Edward Snowden leaked as many as 200,000 classified documents to the media, according to little-noticed public remarks by the eavesdropping agency's chief late last month. NSA Director General Keith Alexander was asked what steps U.S. authorities were taking to stop Snowden from leaking additional information to journalists at a Q&A session in Baltimore October 31. 'I wish there was a way to prevent it. Snowden has shared somewhere between 50 (thousand) and 200,000 documents with reporters. These will continue to come out,' Alexander said. He also warned that these leaks made a terrorist attack more likely. Whistleblower: Former NSA contractor Edward Snowden during a meeting with a German Green Party MP (not pictured) regarding being a witness for a possible investigation into NSA spying in Germany, on October 31. The NSA claim Snowden has leaked up to 200,000 classified documentsAlexander added that the documents were 'being put out in a way that does the maximum damage to NSA and our nation,' according to a transcript of his talk made available by NSA on Thursday. The agency chief claimed it is 'very hard' for the NSA to prevent such leaks. 'But I'll tell you, this increases the probability that a terrorist attack will get through,' he said. 'I think it's absolutely wrong. When we look back on this, people are going to see that and understand that and say what they did was wrong. 'Until then, we're at their mercy. They're putting them out, one or two a week, to cause the maximum problem. They get it wrong.' Concerns: NSA Director General Keith Alexander claimed it is 'very hard' for the NSA to prevent such leaks. 'But I'll tell you, this increases the probability that a terrorist attack will get through,' he saidOfficials briefed on investigations into Snowden's activities have said privately for months that internal government assessments indicate that the number of classified documents to which Snowden got access as a systems operator at NSA installations ran into the hundreds of thousands. Officials said that while investigators now believe they know the range of documents that Snowden accessed, they remain unsure which documents he downloaded for leaking to the media. By comparison, the number of Pentagon and State Department documents leaked to WikiLeaks by a disgruntled U.S. Army private was much larger. The anti-secrecy group obtained around 400,000 Pentagon reports on the Iraq war, as well as 250,000 State Department cables and tens of thousands of documents on U.S. operations in Afghanistan. None of the WikiLeaks material was classified higher than 'Secret' but many NSA documents leaked by Snowden were marked 'Top Secret' or with an even more restrictive 'Special Intelligence' stamp. The material includes highly technical details on U.S. and allied eavesdropping activities. Row: A supporter of the Anonymous group wearing a Guy Fawkes mask holds up a placard featuring a photo of US intelligence leaker Edward Snowden in Berlin. There has been uproar in Germany over reports of NSA spying in EuropeSnowden's revelations, which first surfaced in June, are still causing a headache for the government of President Barack Obama, particularly in its dealing with allies. For example, Germany was outraged by reports that the NSA monitored Chancellor Angela Merkel's cellphone. Alexander also spoke about the report that the NSA had gained access to the phone records of over 70 million French citizens over a 30-day period. The NSA chief said that was aimed at gathering data to support NATO-related activities, adding 'none of that information was collected in France, on French people or European citizens.' 'Yet the uproar in Europe over this is huge,' Alexander said. 'And it's interesting. It's almost like the War of the Worlds.' Matthew Olsen, director of the National Counterterrorism Center in the Office of the Director of National Intelligence, said Snowden's leaks were 'extremely damaging.' 'There is no doubt that those disclosures have made our job harder. We've seen that terrorists or adversaries are seeking to learn about the ways that we collect intelligence and seeking to adapt and change the ways that they communicate,' he told a congressional hearing on Thursday. More to come: Glenn Greenwald (right) has written a series of stories based on material leaked by Edward Snowden. His partner David Miranda (left), a 28-year-old university student, was held and questioned at Heathrow for nearly nine hours in August under terrorism legislation. The NSA believes reporters have many more documents leaked by SnowdenIn the past few days, U.S. officials say, a panel of former officials and experts set up by Obama to review NSA operations in the wake of Snowden's disclosures has privately reported interim conclusions to the White House. The group's final report is due on December 15. The report, along with the White House's own review, is likely to lead to policy changes to be announced by year's end. These are expected to include some constraints on the NSA's wide-ranging eavesdropping. Also included in documents leaked by Snowden are at least 58,000 classified documents generated by Government Communications Headquarters, the NSA's British counterpart, according to UK authorities. Snowden is in Russia, where he was granted asylum in August for at least a year. Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2508058/NSA-chief-says-Edward-Snowden-leaks-increase-probability-terrorist-attack.html#ixzz2knwvgFai Exposing the Dark Forces Behind the Snowden Smears - Carsten Wiethoff - 04-12-2013 So now journalists are potential terrorists and writing an article can be an act of terrorism. How much more can be said about the current state of the "freedom of the press" in this world? See http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-24830684 Quote:The publication of material leaked by Edward Snowden is capable of being an act of terrorism, the home secretary's barrister has said.The claim was made in legal papers in a High Court case in which the partner of Guardian journalist Glenn Greenwald is challenging his detention at Heathrow in August under anti-terror laws. Exposing the Dark Forces Behind the Snowden Smears - Magda Hassan - 04-12-2013 Guilty of journalism. Exposing the Dark Forces Behind the Snowden Smears - Magda Hassan - 21-12-2013 Snowden ally Appelbaum claims his Berlin apartment was invadedJacob Appelbaum, a US Internet activist and one of the people with access to Edward Snowden's documents, has told a Berlin paper that his apartment was broken into, saying he suspected US involvement. Berlin resident and US national Jacob Appelbaum told Saturday's edition of the "Berliner Zeitung" daily that he believed he was under surveillance in the German capital. Appelbaum told the paper that somebody had broken into his apartment and used his computer in his absence. Appelbaum accused the US security services of practicing a policy of subversion or disruptiveness similar to that in the former Communist East Germany. DW.DE[URL="http://www.dw.de/pressure-builds-to-crack-down-on-nsa-spying/a-17307624"]Pressure builds to crack down on NSA spyingNot only is Obama's advisory panel putting pressure on the president, but Congress is also considering two bills aimed at the NSA's spying programs. Will they provide additional protections for non-US citizens? (19.12.2013)[/URL] "The surveillance terrorizes people and supports the much more violent terror of the drone war," Appelbaum, who often draws a link between telecommunications surveillance and unmanned aircraft strikes in countries like Pakistan, Afghanistan and Yemen, told the Berliner Zeitung. Appelbaum moved to Berlin citing better privacy protection in Germany and saying he did not feel safe in the US after a series of airport detentions after trips abroad. The computer security researcher and hacker, a former WikiLeaks representative and spokesman and developer for the "Tor" free software network designed to provide online anonymity, is one of the few people with access to some of the data held by former NSA contractor Edward Snowden. "Currently our communications infrastructure is set up in such a way that the authorities can chime in at any time," Appelbaum said. "The problem is that the NSA therefore always has access to the data. The appropriate approach would be to cut the budgets of the spy agencies and to control them better, furthermore the encryption of communication should be legally guaranteed and the Internet's infrastructure should be altered accordingly." Snowden, formerly a contractor for the National Security Agency (NSA) in the US, went public in June with information about the organization's Internet and telephone espionage practices. Some of Snowden's leaked documents implicated other espionage bodies, not least Britain's GCHQ. German Chancellor Angela Merkel's mobile phone was among the lines tapped, according to Snowden's information. Snowden is currently in Russia, having been granted temporary asylum in August. In August in Berlin, Appelbaum delivered Edward Snowden's acceptance speech after he was awarded the biannual Whistleblower Prize by a group of NGOs. http://www.dw.de/snowden-ally-appelbaum-claims-his-berlin-apartment-was-invaded/a-17315069?maca=en-TWITTER-EN-2004-xml-mrss Exposing the Dark Forces Behind the Snowden Smears - Peter Lemkin - 21-12-2013 Magda Hassan Wrote:Guilty of journalism.Worse than that...Investigative Journalism..... and the worst type of all is, of course, unembedded investigative journalism = treason. Exposing the Dark Forces Behind the Snowden Smears - Peter Lemkin - 21-12-2013 Former CIA Chief: Snowden should be "Hanged by the Neck until Dead"By Joe MullinA very tentative suggestion of amnesty on a CBS program leads to a threat.December 19, 2013 After all the virtual public flogging National Security Agency leaker Edward Snowden has received, in the past week a few voices have suggested cutting him some slack.At a Tuesday closed-door meeting with tech leaders, one unnamed participant suggested to Obama that Snowden be pardoned; Obama said he couldn't do that. During a 60 Minutes report on the leaks that aired Sunday, though, even an NSA official suggested it might be worth discussing amnestyif and only if he returns the leaked documents securely, almost surely an impossibility at this point. (CBS news has been busy defending itself against accusations that Sunday's show was a "puff piece.")Even that tiny, tentative olive branch seems to have crossed a line for security hawks. NSA Director Gen. Keith Alexander dismissed the idea, comparing Snowden to "a hostage taker taking 50 people hostage, shooting 10, and then say[ing], You give me full amnesty and I'll let the other 40 go.'" Former CIA director James Woolsey responded to the suggestion of amnesty even more strongly, saying in a Fox News interview that Snowden should be hanged. "I think giving him amnesty is idiotic," said Woolsey, who ran the CIA from 1993 to 1995. "He should be prosecuted for treason. If convicted by a jury of his peers, he should be hanged by his neck until he is dead." The tough talk on Snowden came the day after a federal judge found the NSA's broad phone surveillance program is likely unconstitutional. US District Judge Richard Leon is the first federal judge to consider the program who does not sit on the secret Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court. http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2013/12/former-cia-chief-snowden-should-be-hanged-by-the-neck-until-dead/ Exposing the Dark Forces Behind the Snowden Smears - David Guyatt - 21-12-2013 Woolsey was, or is, a senior vp at Booz Allen. So absolutely no conflict of interest there then. Snowden released all this information on principle, whereas the duplicitous Woolsey had been named as a war profiteer. Nothing like having double standards is there... Quote: From Washington Note |