Quote:LEE Oswald attended PS 44 for the remainder of 1953, without incident. But where was HARVEY Oswald, and what was he doing in the summer and fall of 1953?

Louise Robertson was a housekeeper, employed by the Marguerite Oswald impostor for 6 weeks in the summer of 1953 to clean her apartment 2 or 3 days per week. Mrs. "Oswald" told Louise that she had brought her son to New York so that he could have mental tests performed at the Jacobi Hospital. Could young HARVEY Oswald, instead of truanting, have been spending some of his days at the Jacobi Hospital?Mrs. Robertson remembered that she was working at their apartment shortly before Mrs. Oswald left New York City, in the summer of 1953, but she did not know where they had gone.

Greg R Parker Wrote:The "Harvey and Lee" inner circle is well aware by now that the Jacobi Hospital did not exist at the time Oswald was in New York.

...

I point out that the above is not what Mrs Robertson said (at least according to the FBI report). What the report actually states is that "Shortly before Oswalds moved. Mrs Oswald told..." She certainly did not know where they had gone. So why has this got Robertson saying mother and son had left NYC?

David Healy Wrote:

Greg R Parker Wrote:The "Harvey and Lee" inner circle is well aware by now that the Jacobi Hospital did not exist at the time Oswald was in New York.

...

I point out that the above is not what Mrs Robertson said (at least according to the FBI report). What the report actually states is that "Shortly before Oswalds moved. Mrs Oswald told..." She certainly did not know where they had gone. So why has this got Robertson saying mother and son had left NYC?

and over the years we've ALL come to know and trust FBI reports, right? LMFAO! Everything the Feebe's putforth is suspect, EVERYTHING! What we need around here are more D. VonPein clones, Geezus!

David Healy Wrote:

Greg R Parker Wrote:The "Harvey and Lee" inner circle is well aware by now that the Jacobi Hospital did not exist at the time Oswald was in New York.

...

I point out that the above is not what Mrs Robertson said (at least according to the FBI report). What the report actually states is that "Shortly before Oswalds moved. Mrs Oswald told..." She certainly did not know where they had gone. So why has this got Robertson saying mother and son had left NYC?

and over the years we've ALL come to know and trust FBI reports, right? LMFAO! Everything the Feebe's putforth is suspect, EVERYTHING! What we need around here are more D. VonPein clones, Geezus!

Greg R Parker Wrote:

David Healy Wrote:

Greg R Parker Wrote:The "Harvey and Lee" inner circle is well aware by now that the Jacobi Hospital did not exist at the time Oswald was in New York.

...

I point out that the above is not what Mrs Robertson said (at least according to the FBI report). What the report actually states is that "Shortly before Oswalds moved. Mrs Oswald told..." She certainly did not know where they had gone. So why has this got Robertson saying mother and son had left NYC?

and over the years we've ALL come to know and trust FBI reports, right? LMFAO! Everything the Feebe's putforth is suspect, EVERYTHING! What we need around here are more D. VonPein clones, Geezus!

And in regard to what the FBI report says, David... what evidence does Armstrong have that shows Ms Robertson told the FBI that Oswald's left NYC ?It's okay to say that FBI reports aren't always reliable, but that does not give anyone carte blanche to make stuff up about what the witness did or didn't say. Unless of course, you're writing fiction.

Greg R Parker Wrote:

Greg R Parker Wrote:

David Healy Wrote:

Greg R Parker Wrote:The "Harvey and Lee" inner circle is well aware by now that the Jacobi Hospital did not exist at the time Oswald was in New York.

...

I point out that the above is not what Mrs Robertson said (at least according to the FBI report). What the report actually states is that "Shortly before Oswalds moved. Mrs Oswald told..." She certainly did not know where they had gone. So why has this got Robertson saying mother and son had left NYC?

and over the years we've ALL come to know and trust FBI reports, right? LMFAO! Everything the Feebe's putforth is suspect, EVERYTHING! What we need around here are more D. VonPein clones, Geezus!

And in regard to what the FBI report says, David... what evidence does Armstrong have that shows Ms Robertson told the FBI that Oswald's left NYC ?It's okay to say that FBI reports aren't always reliable, but that does not give anyone carte blanche to make stuff up about what the witness did or didn't say. Unless of course, you're writing fiction.

I take it this is being conceded, and we'll see the information being amended somewhere?

Dawn Meredith Wrote:

Greg R Parker Wrote:

Greg R Parker Wrote:

David Healy Wrote:and over the years we've ALL come to know and trust FBI reports, right? LMFAO! Everything the Feebe's putforth is suspect, EVERYTHING! What we need around here are more D. VonPein clones, Geezus!

And in regard to what the FBI report says, David... what evidence does Armstrong have that shows Ms Robertson told the FBI that Oswald's left NYC ?It's okay to say that FBI reports aren't always reliable, but that does not give anyone carte blanche to make stuff up about what the witness did or didn't say. Unless of course, you're writing fiction.

I take it this is being conceded, and we'll see the information being amended somewhere?

Greg: I thought you came here to discuss your book. Yet every time I come here you have yet several more fucking threads bashing JA. It's really looking like you have ONE reason for being here. That you have one agenda.
John Armstrong has become a very good friend of mine and frankly I am getting sick of you starting new threads daily just to start arguments over his work, a book you refuse to read.
The always wonderful and brilliant Robert Charles Dunne cautioned me against making our forum a JA forum. I know he sent you the same email, copy of his email to me I mean. But it is you trying to turn this forum into the very last thing John wants. A forum about him. Do you actually do any other JFK research than the Harvey and Lee website?? If so why not post it. This got old long ago. ::headbang::
Dawn

Greg R Parker Wrote:

Greg R Parker Wrote:

David Healy Wrote:

Greg R Parker Wrote:The "Harvey and Lee" inner circle is well aware by now that the Jacobi Hospital did not exist at the time Oswald was in New York.

...

I point out that the above is not what Mrs Robertson said (at least according to the FBI report). What the report actually states is that "Shortly before Oswalds moved. Mrs Oswald told..." She certainly did not know where they had gone. So why has this got Robertson saying mother and son had left NYC?

and over the years we've ALL come to know and trust FBI reports, right? LMFAO! Everything the Feebe's putforth is suspect, EVERYTHING! What we need around here are more D. VonPein clones, Geezus!

And in regard to what the FBI report says, David... what evidence does Armstrong have that shows Ms Robertson told the FBI that Oswald's left NYC ?It's okay to say that FBI reports aren't always reliable, but that does not give anyone carte blanche to make stuff up about what the witness did or didn't say. Unless of course, you're writing fiction.

I take it this is being conceded, and we'll see the information being amended somewhere?

Curious - has there been any mention of a REASON the FBI needed to know where/when Oswald attended 7th and 8th grade by Nov 27th - I can't see how this would help the investigation - yet it seems incredibly important for the FBI to sort out within that first week... ::

Better yet GP... how did Mrs Robertson come to the attention of the FBI to begin with and why?

Here's an idea Mr P... read the book, look thru the CD and review the Baylor notebooks so you don't so sound so incredibly lost while you try and cherry-pick from the thousands of pages of evidence to make incomplete and unsupportable posts offering only uninformed opinions presented as "facts"... and then not correcting yourself when you are repeatedly shown the errors in your approach, your analysis and your conclusions

::

Dawn Meredith Wrote:

Greg R Parker Wrote:

Greg R Parker Wrote:

David Healy Wrote:and over the years we've ALL come to know and trust FBI reports, right? LMFAO! Everything the Feebe's putforth is suspect, EVERYTHING! What we need around here are more D. VonPein clones, Geezus!

And in regard to what the FBI report says, David... what evidence does Armstrong have that shows Ms Robertson told the FBI that Oswald's left NYC ?It's okay to say that FBI reports aren't always reliable, but that does not give anyone carte blanche to make stuff up about what the witness did or didn't say. Unless of course, you're writing fiction.

I take it this is being conceded, and we'll see the information being amended somewhere?

Greg: I thought you came here to discuss your book. Yet every time I come here you have yet several more fucking threads bashing JA. It's really looking like you have ONE reason for being here. That you have one agenda.
John Armstrong has become a very good friend of mine and frankly I am getting sick of you starting new threads daily just to start arguments over his work, a book you refuse to read.
The always wonderful and brilliant Robert Charles Dunne cautioned me against making our forum a JA forum. I know he sent you the same email, copy of his email to me I mean. But it is you trying to turn this forum into the very last thing John wants. A forum about him. Do you actually do any other JFK research than the Harvey and Lee website?? If so why not post it. This got old long ago. ::headbang::
Dawn