Anyone want to discuss HARVEY & LEE?

[Bernice Moore]

some marguerites...b

[Steve Duffy]

Is the info at Baylor available online? how to us at the bottom of the world get access to it? I know I've bookmarked the contents, but I'd like to read Armstrong's info on Norton at some point...
Dawn, with your view of Harvey and Lee, and your belief in Judyth's story, what do you feel are the main points of divergence? If she new Harvey, well, wasn't he the man Armstrong claims to not be able to drive?(My minds a sieve, so forgive me if I have trouble getting everything I read confused. Also, if this is of topic, then a pm would be great. At least you have shown surprise at JVB's (reluctance?) towards Armstrong's work, which you and I both think is fantastic.
Steve

[Brian Anderson]

Hello Again Friends

Here is another question that pops up again as I re-read Harvey and Lee. Harvey joins the Marines in October of 1956, for a three year stint. (p.146), He begins work at Pfisterer's Dental Laboratory, in October of 1957 (p.173) and then quits Pfisterer's in May of 1958 (p.192) and returns to Ft. Worth. My question is, how can Harvey be in the Marines and yet, at the same time, be working at Pfisterer's Lab for about eight months? Does Armstrong provide an answer for this? Perhaps I have missed it.

Brian

[Peter Lemkin]

I would like to see Armstrong critique Ed Haslam's details on JVB and her 'Lee'; as well as Ed Haslam comment on Harvey and Lee in the context of his work...or someone else try to find the areas of overlap [if any]; dissonance; areas that need fleshing out. Armstrong had done a more scholarly work, but no work is ever complete or without flaws or could be ammended with new information. I know J.A. is pretty much out of the JFK loop now, feeling [rightly] he did 'his part'. Haslam is more active now. I suggest he and others try to compare and contrast times, incidents, dates, personages that agree, disagree, clash or need further investigation.:girl:

[Jack White]

Is the info at Baylor available online? how to us at the bottom of the world get access to it? I know I've bookmarked the contents, but I'd like to read Armstrong's info on Norton at some point...
Dawn, with your view of Harvey and Lee, and your belief in Judyth's story, what do you feel are the main points of divergence? If she new Harvey, well, wasn't he the man Armstrong claims to not be able to drive?(My minds a sieve, so forgive me if I have trouble getting everything I read confused. Also, if this is of topic, then a pm would be great. At least you have shown surprise at JVB's (reluctance?) towards Armstrong's work, which you and I both think is fantastic.
Steve

Armstrong's papers will be online sometime in 2011,

Jack

[Jack White]

Hello Again Friends

Here is another question that pops up again as I re-read Harvey and Lee. Harvey joins the Marines in October of 1956, for a three year stint. (p.146), He begins work at Pfisterer's Dental Laboratory, in October of 1957 (p.173) and then quits Pfisterer's in May of 1958 (p.192) and returns to Ft. Worth. My question is, how can Harvey be in the Marines and yet, at the same time, be working at Pfisterer's Lab for about eight months? Does Armstrong provide an answer for this? Perhaps I have missed it.

Brian

You have answered your own question. As shown by H&L,
LHO cannot be in two places at once. Armstrong provides
the evidence. You supply the answer the evidence poses to
a reasonable person.

As I read your question, you may have misinterpreted the
evidence. Reread the portion in question and get back to
us.

Jack

[Jack White]

I would like to see Armstrong critique Ed Haslam's details on JVB and her 'Lee'; as well as Ed Haslam comment on Harvey and Lee in the context of his work...or someone else try to find the areas of overlap [if any]; dissonance; areas that need fleshing out. Armstrong had done a more scholarly work, but no work is ever complete or without flaws or could be ammended with new information. I know J.A. is pretty much out of the JFK loop now, feeling [rightly] he did 'his part'. Haslam is more active now. I suggest he and others try to compare and contrast times, incidents, dates, personages that agree, disagree, clash or need further investigation.:girl:

Armstrong feels any time spent on JVB is a waste of time.

Haslam ought to read it and comment, as you suggest.

Jack

[Brian Anderson]

Hello Again Friends

Here is another question that pops up again as I re-read Harvey and Lee. Harvey joins the Marines in October of 1956, for a three year stint. (p.146), He begins work at Pfisterer's Dental Laboratory, in October of 1957 (p.173) and then quits Pfisterer's in May of 1958 (p.192) and returns to Ft. Worth. My question is, how can Harvey be in the Marines and yet, at the same time, be working at Pfisterer's Lab for about eight months? Does Armstrong provide an answer for this? Perhaps I have missed it.

Brian

You have answered your own question. As shown by H&L,
LHO cannot be in two places at once. Armstrong provides
the evidence. You supply the answer the evidence poses to
a reasonable person.

As I read your question, you may have misinterpreted the
evidence. Reread the portion in question and get back to
us.

Jack

Jack

I have re-read those passages and I don't think I have misinterpreted them. I certainly am not calling into question John Armstrong's timeline of places and events. On page 165, Armstrong writes; "A thorough investigation, however, would have disclosed the names of dozens of Marines who remembered Harvey Oswald and Felde in California (thru April 1957), Jacksonville (May), Biloxi (June), and Memphis (August/Sept). Now, after attending the Aviation Electronics school in Memphis, Harvey may have attempted to enter the Antioch College in Yellow Springs, Ohio (pp.166-167) Armstrong, then says that Harvey left for New Orleans. If Lee [B]Harvey[]Oswald was in Yellow Springs, Ohio for a few weeks in the fall of 1957, he soon left and moved to New Orleans. (p.167) In New Orleans, of course, [B]Harvey begins working at Pfisterer's in October of 1957 (p.173) and quits in May of 1958 (p.192). Perhaps this employment at Pfisterer's was part of the manner in which Harvey was being "handled"? Anyway after returning to Ft. Worth Harvey "...towards the end of the summer, left Ft. Worth, travelled to Atsugi, and then to Taiwan...(p.196) Now that sounds more like Marine activity.

Any thoughts?

Oh, by the way Jack, I had the pleasure of meeting you at ASK 92. You sat down at the table, at which, my brother and I were having a quick snack during a break. One of your arms was in a sling. You told me that you had been assaulted.

Brian

[Bernice Moore]

these were scanned from ''alias oswald ''by r.b cutler and morris 1984 some years back; not near John's book, but all we had for many a year..:wavey:

they include dates and show the differences between the two, including weight height, eye colour etc, medical...fwtaw..

they may help show that there were two distinctly different men..imo..b..if i can upload them, fingers crossed they will....they positively will...b they worked they uploaded and i can sees em...:wavey:

[Bernice Moore]

one more time a few more...b:wavey: