Judyth Vary Baker: Living in Exile

[Jack White]

Jim...it is apparent that THERE IS A SIX-INCH DIFFERENCE
IN HEIGHT IN THE TWO WOMEN.

I am NOT going to tell you to read the book. Just look at the
two photos, which are scaled the same. The Marguerite I knew
was about 5 feet tall. The Marguerite in the group photo is about
5 foot 7 inches. It is a very simple concept to comprehend@

Jack

Jack,

Just to adopt the weakest shadow of the attitude you have displayed toward Judyth, why should anyone take for granted that these photographs "prove" anything like you describe? Judyth has shown that the same woman during her life span can display very different physical appearances. Their quality is so very different as when you offer photos of the "two Oswalds". And you know what can happen when the same photograph is scanned over and over again. You make the impeccable point that, if there were TWO at the SAME TIME who were using the same name MARGUERITE and raising sons named OSWALD who were living PARALLEL LIVES, then you would have proven your case. But surely you can't expect that producing a photograph like this is sufficient to convince anyone of the (on its face) implausible theory you and John have advanced. You may be right--and I know you are convinced that you ARE right--but I and no doubt others remain to be convinced. Just for openers--and Judyth will have questions and comments of her own--how do we know the origin of these photographs at all? I know you are going to tell me to READ THE BOOK. I just want you to know that sorting all this out may take some time. Just as you are demanding about Judyth, I shall be demanding of you.

Jim

For those who have not read Armstrong and who do not believe that there were two Marguerites: