09-03-2016, 06:55 AM
Tom Scully Wrote:Scott Kaiser Wrote:...............
Let me try this in a different way the information you posted here is information complied by corresponds apparently between JFK and JKG. And, what this information is suggesting is that prior to Kennedy sending JKG to India as the Ambassador to India he should stop by Vietnam and report to JFK about the ongoing situation, and why wouldn't he if Vietnam is only 3-3.5 hours flight from India.
Now, this report was an apparent report written by JKG and mailed to Kennedy, JKG starts off by saying "here's my full analysis" in his letter to the president and it reflects the letter by this transcript correct? However, the letter in question does not exist at the JFK Library or NARA, neither have a copy of JKG's "letter" analysis other then what you have provided here in this package. Now, someone lied to someone and this information ended up in this package, why is that so hard to believe? Have I not said it any clearer in any of my past posts or is this what you're going to hanging onto?
I'll stay up late, anticipating an apology!
Tom Scully Wrote:Scott Kaiser Wrote:I do apologize, I said there are letters of Galbraith reporting to the president of the urgency to reconsider Vietnam, I sincerely believed there was, however, I cannot find one, does that also discredit me? I don't know, however, I did, though all the hoopla and posts by many top notch researchers come to believe as they did that Galbraith did write a letter regarding Vietnam, sadly, there is none.
~Scott Kaiser
Scott, I am bothering to present the evidence that should influence you (if you were a reasonable person) to hide your head in shame and apologize, then fall silent, and contemplate your methods!
The following are arranged in chronological order, from November 3, 1961.:
.........
Tom Scully Wrote:"Training wheels" version, chronological order -
Scott, I am bothering to present the evidence (again, see page 1, bottom, of this thread) that should influence you (if you were a reasonable person) to hide your head in shame and apologize, then fall silent, and contemplate your methods!
The following are arranged in chronological order, from November 3, 1961.:
Quote:https://history.state.gov/historicaldocu...63v01/d209............
Foreign Relations of the United States, 19611963
Volume I, Vietnam, 1961, Document 209
209. Paper Prepared by the Ambassador to India (Galbraith)[SUP]1[/SUP]
Washington, November 3, 1961.
A PLAN FOR SOUTH VIETNAM
The situation in South Viet-Nam is perilously close to the point of no return.....
.......
[SUP]1[/SUP] Source: Kennedy Library, President's Office File, Viet-Nam Country Series, Security 1961. Secret. The source text was attached to a signed letter of November 3 from Galbraith to the President, which reads in full: "You asked for my views on Vietnam. They are set forth in this paper. I might add that they are shared by Abe Chayes, who has collaborated with me in preparing the paper." Galbraith was in Washington for the State visit of Prime Minister Nehru
Scott, if I had known you have no reading comprehension skills, I would not have wasted my time presenting a condensed
version, after you complained about the length of my first attempt to inform you with primary sources. You are too lazy to confirm when Galbraith even began his service as U.S. Ambassador to India! I presented this twice to you, as I have proved above.:
Quote:[SUP]1[/SUP] Source: Kennedy Library, President's Office File, Viet-Nam Country Series, Security 1961. Secret. The source text was attached to a signed letter of November 3 from Galbraith to the President, which reads in full: "You asked for my views on Vietnam. They are set forth in this paper. I might add that they are shared by Abe Chayes, who has collaborated with me in preparing the paper." Galbraith was in Washington for the State visit of Prime Minister Nehru
See:
[URL="https://books.google.com/books?id=AgK6BwAAQBAJ&pg=PA586&dq=galbraith+saigon+november+1961&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjO0re38KzLAhXCWD4KHTn7AAEQ6AEIMzAC#v=onepage&q&f=true"]https://books.google.com/books?id=AgK6BwAAQBAJ&pg=PA586&dq=galbraith+saigon+november+1961&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjO0re38KzLAhXCWD4KHTn7AAEQ6AEIMzAC#v=onepage&q&f=true
[/URL]
Okay, again allow me to try this in a different way, your next post to me better be the letter itself, with JKG's signature at the bottom as he has always signed his letters with his stationary letter head otherwise everything else that your posting is nothing but false disseminated information over the years. Tom can you do that, it's real simply Tom, can you see how easy it is for you to post this information you've been providing from the getgo that all I ask of you is to now provide me the letter. Listen Tom, allow me to repeat myself because understand does not seem to be one of your strong suites. Now Tom, please don't provide another book or another transcript, Tom, please provide me the letter can you do that for me Tom? Thanks!