02-06-2011, 05:51 AM
Ed Jewett Wrote:I did note (did you?) that the link from which the video and argument was taken had at least seven prior posts on the same matter.No, the poorly reasoned arguments on the page you linked didn't inspire me to look into the blog any further.
Ed Jewett Wrote:You have said that you would be happy to oblige in discussing the matter, so have at it. State a thesis, or tear this one down.I said that if you are interested in discussing the matter I'd be happy to oblige, using the term "discuss" in its primary sense, as in a conversation between two or more people. That's why I posted the videos in my first reply to this thread, as I believe they do well to tear down claim in the video you linked. However, I'm not going to go stabbing in the dark as to why you haven't acknowledged that response, or as to whatever other arguments for video fakery you might find compelling.