27-05-2012, 02:19 PM
Seamus Coogan Wrote:Charles Drago Wrote:Seamus Coogan Wrote:Of course Jim Di knows that stuff lol. But when you get Jim Di and Lisa Pease saying something is a crock of shite like Janney is. I'm sorry to say your going into chronic over kill mate! Crump could just have been a psychopath and Meyer could have been at the wrong place at the wrong time. Sometimes as Magda says "A cigar is just a cigar".
Sorry, Seamus, but Jim and Lisa would be the last two people to endorse the logical fallacy of argument from authority.
And to continue your Deep Politics 101 and Logic 101 education: Even if they or anyone else could disprove convincingly Janney's hypothesis, it would tell us nothing about the nature of Mary Pinchot Meyer's demise other than it likely did not happen the way Janney describes.
The simplest explanation of Meyer's death that includes an appreciation of context: the murder was a deep political act.
Their points are good enough for me. Sorry your's and others take on it are not. That's my opinion. Harden up and accept it.
I like you CD, I like you a lot. but I'm getting sick and tired of this "you don't get Deep Politics wankery" or you giving me the a working class son of a trade unionists and political activists not to mention anti U.S spy base protestors and is mates with people like Nicky Hager and Mike Frost (guys who ousted the Echelon system) Have you heard of that Charles? Thats pretty deeply political don't you think? I have deep political insight as much as any body else on this forum. I just apply caution. Forgive me for being cautious in a mine field. Just because you buy this Janney tripe doesn't make me think your a moron does it?
Forgive my being caustic. But I've had a shitty day and I despair of a wildly intelligent and marvelous fellow being a condescending arrogant poo.
Yawn.