America needs change

[Alik Bahshi]

Topof Form

Alik Bahshi

Israel, and the simple truth


"The simple truth is rarely is clear - never simple"
OscarWilde

Civilization experience shows thatall human intervention in nature, proved wrong. Human society is also part ofnature, and though the man carries the possibility of a comprehensive art,civilization developed on their own, independent of human laws. One historicalformation gave way to another without meaningful participation focused on aman, that is not created first ideology social structure, which is thenfollowed humanity. Philosophers and historians had only to establish the factof the transition from the slave system to the feudal system and then tocapitalism without theoretical justification of the inevitable emergence of afuture formation.

In the late 19th century, in additionto other major discoveries in the natural world have been offered twoideologies (Communism and Zionism), which, though not proved valuable in termsof philosophy in relation to the first or general social significance for asecond, but that left a significant mark in the history of that have beenimplemented in practice.

One - Karl Marx considered inevitablereplacement of capitalism by the Communist era as a new social system, a kindof earthly paradise for mankind. Attempting to put this ideology into practicewas made in Russia duress claim the destruction of the Russian intelligentsiaand active business executives. Experiment over the society was no less bloodythan the era of medieval obscurantism, lasted 70 years, with the entry of theworld proletarian revolution club, and ended in failure. It should be noted,originally initiated the experiment were mainly representatives of Jewish, thenthey are also becoming dissidents, and ran out of the country they have createda "communist paradise".
I do not want a detailed discussion of theerror of the communist ideology, but, in my opinion, the main reason for itsfailure was that it was intended to create a new man, a certain individualcommunist type, based on the absurd assumption that the environment and theconditions of education could change the very nature of man. Therefore, theideology of communism and praised to the skies by schemers Science AcademicianLysenko, rejecting genetics, calling her a capitalist pseudoscience.

Another - the ideology of Zionism,Theodor Herzl, was less global in nature and involves the goal of creating astate for the Jewish people. It was assumed that Jews from around the worldwill gather in one place in the world. Incredible and in some cases even funny,if you search for the territory of the future Jewish state considered and SouthAmerica, and Africa, and the Crimea, before settling on Palestine. However, itshould be noted that instead of Crimea Stalin singled out for the land of theJews in the Far East, where he organized the Jewish Autonomous Region. Thisfact suggests that the idea of ​​Zionism took place and one of the leaders ofthe Great October Socialist Revolution in Russia, most of whom were Jews. Withhigh probability we can assume that if a confrontation between Stalin andTrotsky (Bronstein) up to take the last, to be Jewish Crimea republic.
In the end, after considerablefinancial costs and diplomacy after quite a large time span, including twoWorld Wars and the Holocaust, Zionism, the idea became reality the UN decisionto allocate part of the territory of Palestine for the Jewish state. However,the program of Zionism was not performed in full, because it is not able togather all the Jews in Israel. The Jews did not want to leave the safecountries for the promised land of Israel and mostly settled Jews from EasternEuropean countries, North Africa and the Middle East, based on all possibleassistance to the Jewish organizations to encourage repatriation, if it is atall possible to use the term. The fact that the Jews are all those who believein Judaism, but this does not mean that the Jews are ethnically one people.European Jews are different from Moroccan Jews, not only in appearance andtraditions, but also the mentality, in fact, even in Israel, their faith hadnot united, if we take into account that they are praying to everyone in theirsynagogues. Well, about the Ethiopian Jews, and can not speak. For example, theKhazars, before accepting Islam a short time were Jews, so what do they haveceased to be the Khazars. Therefore, the word "repatriation" is notthe same as back home. It's like as if to say "repatriation ofChristians." Well, where should they be repatriated? However, in the firstapproximation, the Crusades can also be interpreted as the repatriation ofEuropean Christians to the homeland of the Faith in the promised land.
But let us leave aside thesearguments and look at the facts, because only they reflect reality: the stateof Israel exists, and it is strong economically and it is even more strongly inthe military, compared with the surrounding Arab countries. Here it isnecessary to take into account the very important fact that the magnitude ofIsrael so he and dependent on a single, but a powerful ally - the UnitedStates, an ally, without whose help it is difficult to imagine the possibilityof the existence of the Jewish state. The fact that the well-known reasons,since the formation of Israel was at war with the Arabs and introduced half acentury ago, the martial law has not been canceled today. Obviously, such asmall country like Israel can not so long alone against hostile environment andAmerica's role as an ally invaluable.

However, the policy is pragmatic andtherefore a reasonable question that America wins the friendship with Israel,can cause confusion and bewilderment. Is there a clear answer, whatspecifically has positive dividends America, being in the military andpolitical alliance with Israel. Sometimes the arguments in favor of analliance, they see that, they say, Israel is an outpost of democracy in theMiddle East. But can a country with no constitution, the country in which thereis no separation of executive and legislative powers, the country in whichreligion is not separated from the state, the country with socialist principlesof management, when major financial and manufacturing facilities are in thehands of the state, and, finally, the country carrying out the policy ofapartheid to a part of its population, to be called democratic? And if aprincipled approach to this issue, the outpost of democracy in the Middle Eastis not Israel, and Turkey. Reason Union of America and Israel is a completelydifferent plane, and explains a significant share of the participation ofAmerican Jews in the financial and, as a consequence, the political life of thecountry. It is thanks to the Jewish lobby Congress of the United States isspending a lot of funds from the state budget to help Israel, supported by themilitary and political patronage. U.S. taxpayer money to these disappear intothe sands of the Middle Eastern, not bringing any benefit America. Furthermore,as a belligerent ally, America is putting himself under enemy attack. Permanentwar between Israel and the Palestinians crossed the ocean and the tragedy ofSeptember 11 is the result of the bloody Middle East show, which put the Jewishlobby on American money. For the Jewish lobby interests of Israel is moreimportant than the interests of America. Blocking perfectly valid UN SecurityCouncil resolution condemning Israel's occupation of Arab territories, theUnited States is forced to use the policy of double standards. With thedecision to crack down on al-Qaeda, begins continuous string of policy failuresof President Bush, because of all that had taken the American president, it isnot commendable.

If not for close ties with Israel,America would have no problems with the Arabs. America has been and is a majorproblem with the Russian. Moscow, using the Arab-Israeli conflict, the Arabcountries trying to attract to their side, to change in their favor thestrategic situation in the Middle East, the main supplier of oil to the West.Even today, the idea strangle strategic adversary fuel shortage still burn inthe minds of Kremlin strategists. By the way, here we note that in the case ofIsrael and the Arabs pacifying Russian finally lose hope in the plan. Andhere's the paradox: real peace between the Arabs and the Jews do not wanteither Russian or Jewish law, in spite of fierce mutual hatred. Verily, fromlove to hate - one step.

In my view, the main factorhindering peace between Israel and the Arabs, is the overseas patriotism ofAmerican Jews, who created the Jewish lobby in Congress, have an impact on U.S.policy toward the Arab-Israeli conflict, and political life in Israel. Far fromthe real situation in Israel, they support the aggressive intentions of theIsraeli right in terms of the obstacles a Palestinian state and the annexationof the territories of neighboring Syria and Lebanon; It is important to notethat in its aggressiveness towards the Arabs Jews of America have surpassedthemselves Israelis. Over the last 10 - 15 years of Israeli society polevelomarkedly, despite the fact that it poured nearly one million immigrants from theSoviet Union, which is 99 percent completely ardent opponents of the stateproviding Palestinian Arabs. For a complete understanding of the need toconsider a very important detail, which is that, unfortunately, Soviet Jewshave imperial worldview, which they had acquired in the USSR and, weighed downby this luggage, went to other countries. This fact seems at first sightphenomenon, but quite understandable. If the presence of a Russian imperialideology, as a state-forming people (creative discovery Russian nationalists inlinguistics), is not objectionable, Soviet Jews have acquired it as a result ofthe revolution and the USSR. The fact that the Jews perceived the Soviet Unionas a whole, for they were not the indigenous people to the territory habitat.In addition, Jews were pioneers of the socialist revolution, and in themajority of the leaders of the Communists. Using the slogan "Workers ofthe world unite", they managed to unite the people of the empire whobelieved in a "bright future of communism." The truth of the peoplewho came to power, mostly, say no ethnic Russian proletarians and was not eventhere! If we consider that in the minds of the Russian people, except imperialideology is present and Russian chauvinism, which was pointed out by Stalin soloved by the people, it is certain that other nations of the empire meant theunenviable role of younger brothers. In these circumstances, the Soviet Jewswere cementing this nation of the Soviet Union, which had an impact on theirworld, which they retained, leaving the country collapsed.
Following interesting fact: despitestrong patriotic feelings and love for Israel, Soviet Jews flocked to America,and, oddly enough, in Germany, the country that because of certain historicalevents, it would seem difficult to choose the Promised Land. By the way, it ispossible, if not for the Holocaust, it could not have taken place and theJewish state in Palestine. It is hard to blame the people who want a betterlife, which is all one, for lack of patriotism, if we take into account thatfor most of them, Israel is the homeland for which worth risking the well-beingand even lives. The place where the faith was born, does not always coincidewith the concept of homeland. For example, remember once again the Khazars, whotook a short while Judaism. For them, Israel is certainly not way side couldnot be home, however, did not they and the Arabs to accept Islam.
To redirect the flow of Jewishimmigrants to Israel, where he is vital to change the demographic situationdeveloping in the future not to the state as a Jewish, World Jewish Congressmanaged to get from America to Israel release 10 billion dollars for thereception of immigrants from the Soviet Union and thus close America. So therewas a Great Aliyah 90s, came to Israel about a million Jews. Many of them stilllater moved to the United States and Canada, not only maintaining patriotism,but even more showing thus
aggressive intentions towards the Palestinians, calling from overseas stayingin Israel for stronger military actions against the Palestinians. For example,former Russian-language Israeli journalist, once in New York, literally climbsout of the skin, strongly urging Israelis not to conduct peace negotiationswith the Palestinians and not to leave the occupied territories. Yes, from adistance everything seems easier and immense courage, especially when yourmilitant calls that lead to nowhere, should exercise more.
More than half a century, continuingArab-Israeli conflict, which sometimes unintentionally become and neutralcountries, as scores between Jews and Arabs are reduced wherever possible,across borders and fighting techniques. Taken hostage, abducted planes explodehotels in Buenos Aires, and Istanbul, undermined cars and handsets. Like afunnel tightened in depth reduction of the country, whose people do far fromthe Middle East conflict. For example, the Afghan people have fallen victim tothis conflict, because Bush is in pursuit of bin Laden, started a war against theTaliban, which are quite far from the explanation of the relationship betweenArabs and Jews. If we take into account that there is no Pashtun border betweenAfghanistan and Pakistan, it is theoretically theater of war could spill overinto Pakistan. But I think before that it will not come, because Bush does nothave at this time a fatal mistake. Destabilize the nuclear power - a verydangerous idea.

All attempts to crush Palestinianresistance is futile. While Israel had used all possible military action, werenot used, except that only napalm bomb. If at least some would be militaryaction by Israel could solve the problem, it would have long been realized. Innature, there is simply no such opportunity to force the Palestinians to giveup their freedom. Violence problem is not solved. Moreover, there is a trendthreatening putting Israel position both in terms of the political and themilitary. Only in this way can be interpreted as withdrawal from Gaza and acomplete failure in the Second Lebanon. Right camp, killing of Yitzhak Rabinand foolishly rejected the Saudi peace initiative, brings the country to ruin.Without peace with the Arabs, Israel has no future, but the world is becomingmore elusive.

In my view, the United Nations madea big mistake by taking a decision on the division of Palestine into twostates, without providing them with reasonable safety and giving the Jews andthe Arabs themselves to observe the boundary between the Jewish and Arabstates. The UN should have foreseen that a confrontation is inevitable andnecessary presence of a third force on the line of the boundary section isobvious.
It's time to fix the problem andput the UN troops to Israel, dividing Jews and Arabs on the border, used to bea prescribed solution. Other real option to end the Middle East conflict today,no. However, there is one hypothetical output - is to give the Palestiniansequal rights to the Jews, but in order to preserve the Jewish character of thestate, it is necessary that the majority of American Jews moved to Israel. Bythe way, at last, be fully realized goal of Zionism to gather all the Jews inone state. But from that moment there are some tough questions.
If American Jews will move to Israel, they will lose their representation inthe government of the United States and Israel certainly lose the traditionalsupport that he owed the Jewish lobby. Withdrawal of Jews from Americanpolitical life can not affect the political and economic situation of theJewish state. How to behave like American politicians, freed from the pressurethey felt by the Jewish lobby? On the other hand it is doubtful that the Jews,being in Israel, will maintain their financial well-being, which they had inAmerica. The fact that it was achieved in an environment of other people andnot the fact that the Jews in the Holy Land to keep the same level of wealth,which they had in the Diaspora.
The peoples of different mentality:- a sort of hereditary constant defining the people, their character, behavior,visual contrast and even the way of life. For example, if you give Roma theground, say, treat it, let it feeds you, build a house, the word live on it asyou see fit. The next morning, you will not find them there. They have adifferent way of being. They will not do in his "stealing horses."

However, the story does not sufferthe fate of the subjunctive interpretation and all goes to the fact that theinternational community will be forced to enter into Israel international forcethat will set the state border dividing the two countries. UN must correct amistake made half a century ago.
It is hoped that Zionism does not suffer the fate of Communism.

"Fate and history is written by the same hand"
Paulo Coelho
Нажмите, чтобы отредактировать или просмотреть другие варианты перевода
Чтобы изменить порядок слов, перетаскивайте их, удерживая клавишу Shift
[TABLE="class: MsoNormalTable"]
[TR]
[TD="bgcolor: transparent"]
[TABLE="class: MsoNormalTable, width: 100%"]
[TR]
[TD="width: 100%, bgcolor: transparent"][/TD]
[/TR]
[/TABLE]


[TABLE="class: MsoNormalTable, width: 100%"]
[TR]
[TD="width: 100%, bgcolor: transparent"][/TD]
[/TR]
[/TABLE]


[TABLE="class: MsoNormalTable, width: 100%"]
[TR]
[TD="bgcolor: transparent"][/TD]
[TD="width: 54, bgcolor: transparent"][/TD]
[/TR]
[/TABLE]
[/TD]
[/TR]
[/TABLE]