27-03-2014, 04:33 AM
Jim Hargrove Wrote:So, Parker is moving us along to a new topic, now that he has declared victory a dozen times or more in the tonsillectomy thread he started before this one. In that previous thread, Parker concluded that the tonsillectomy Marguerite Oswald THOUGHT her son had undergone was FAKED by "the quack Philben," although, he tells us, "Marguerite honestly believed the tonsils had been removed."
Can't argue with logic like that! Case closed!
Where did you get these documents, Greg, and how can we verify them from the source?
The ONLY people claiming victory were you and Josephs. You are doing so again here albeit in an arrogant and sarcastic manner.
But just to keep you happy - it's a no-brainer. There was no tonsillectomy and you guys got your knickers all twisted by it. So yes. The argument was not one you were ever going to win - and it is a pattern you ha better become accustomed to.
The documents are easily obtainable online from various genealogy sites.
You are not going to claim that someone put up faked documents in the hope that a JFK researcher would come along and be fooled by them I hope?
Your reliance on the memory of witnesses - both real as in Pic and completely bogus as in Kudlaty is a fatal flaw.