20-09-2014, 09:12 PM
Drew Phipps Wrote:William Charleston Wrote:How could it be possible that a reasonable scenario of BANG-BANG, JFK's head shot and then Connally's back is not published anywhere except by me?
I'm not arguing that your scenario is unreasonable. I'm arguing that the acoustic evidence isn't taken seriously by researchers for the very good reasons cited above. In addition, I'm (as of about a week ago) no longer willing to believe that the Zapruder film is necesarily an accurate recording of the assassination (there are other recent threads concerning this issue on this forum). Since your work involves comparing the acoustic evidence, to the Zapruder film, you are depending on the validity of them both.
What's left is comparing witness recollections, common sense, and the physics of momentum.
If the acoustical evidence is not valid, then how did the acoustical experts identify shots that correspond almost exactly (within 0.1 second resolution) to the Zapruder film? For it to be invalid,
1. the acoustical experts would have to have been extremely lucky to have showed there was 4.8 seconds between two of the shots which corresponds with the shots at Z224 and Z313.
2. The acoustical experts would have had to have just been incredibly lucky again to show the last two shots were BANG-BANG (0.7 seconds apart) exactly like over 30 witnesses said happened (after the government said those sounds were echoes the press then ignored the dozens of witnesses who said BANG-BANG). WHY did only the last shot echo and not earlier shots? Easily answered when you look at the acoustical evidence.
3. The acoustical experts were lucky again when they showed the last shot was fired EXACTLY like John Connally said that he was bent over by the force of the bullet hitting him in his back.
4. the acoustical experts would have had to have been lucky again to have shown the last three shots were fired in this order (direction matches the film again):
Z224 from behind from TSBD
Z313 from the grassy knoll that knocked JFK back directly away from the gunman on the grassy knoll
Z325 The shot missed JFK's head and hit Connally in the back, driving him forward
5. With the last three shots aligned to the Zapruder film AND the corresponding wounds identified, it is not possible those three shots caused all of the wounds and damage seen during the shooting. The acoustical experts would have had to have been extremely lucky again to have shown there were two shots fired before Z224 that allow reasonable explanations consistent with what many witnesses say happened.
6. The latest acoustical analysis shows that there were THREE shots fired from the TSBD corresponding with witnesses who were in the TSBD who clearly heard three shots from that location. Were they lucky again to get this right too?
ETC.
Do you think the HSCA acoustical experts guessed 4.8 seconds and 0.7 seconds for shot spacing that matches the Z film? NOTE: The Zapruder forgery changed what you see, it did not significantly change the timing of the events.
You may never believe that the timing of the acoustical evidence with the Zapruder film proves that a powerful conspiracy killed JFK but eventually many will because it makes sense where the other guesses (and lies) fall far short of being reasonable.
I keep plugging away presenting what I am positive is correct because every once in a while, someone gets it!
.......I stumbled across your video. Bingo! All these years have gone by and it never occurred to me that Connally was shot after JFK's fatal head shot. Once you're walked through it, it's immediately evident that that's exactly what happened. It all fits! It's the ONLY thing that fit's.It's amazing work. You're the VERY first person to put this all together. Congrats!! Watching your video was like putting glasses on correctly after wearing them backwards for years without realizing it. Everything immediately became clear!! THANK-YOU for your great work and for posting your video online. Please keep spreading the word about it and continuing your work!
Not one of the researchers who you apparently listen to realizes that the timing of the Zapruder film and the acoustical evidence matches when you correct for mistakes made by the HSCA. If you use Bugliosi's RECLAIMING HISTORY or any other book, you will not get the timing right. The HSCA concluded there were four shots but I have been showing there was an additional shot. The HSCA would have gotten the right answer eventually because the first shooting experiment was done with the test microphones very far apart which gave weak correlation to the actual recording. When the microphones would have been bunched up closer for the next shooting experiment, the matches would have been much closer and the conclusions would have been much stronger statistically. But the US government did not let the next shooting experiment happen, they said they ran out of money! What that means is they couldn't let the acoutical experts do the second shooting experiment because that would have removed all doubt. They decided it's better that you keep guessing rather than letting the public know for sure who was behind the brutal murder of JFK.
Shots #1, 3 and 5: Fired from TSBD
Shot #1 Z178 slightly wounded James Tague
Shot #2 Z202 Fired a split second before JFK disappears behind sign, JFK can be seen reacting before Connally reacts to Z224 shot
Shot #3 Z224 One of the fired shots from TSBD could not be metal jacket bullet due to Parkland Hospital CE399 plant. It fragemented when it hit a branch, caused a wound to JFK's back 5.5 inches below his collar (during autopsy, it was said shallow wound, no point of exit), another fragment hit Connally's left thigh, other fragments hit street (several witnesses independtly saw something hit the street), CE840: Three bullet fragments found under Nellie's seat near John Connally's left thigh
Shot #4: Z313 Per Roy Kellerman, he saw a small wound just forward of JFK's right ear in the hairline about the size of the end of his small finger and he identified a massive exit wound in the right rear of JFK's head EXACTLY like the Parkland doctors say they saw.
Shot #5: Z325 3rd shot from TSBD missed JFK's head and hit Connally in the back bending him over. The bullet exited his chest and hit the top of his wrist. As identified earlier in this thread, the bullet hit the TOP of Connally's wrist which means he could not have been wounded until after Z313 when his right wrist was again in front of his body as seen from the TSBD. Before Z313, Connally's palm was turned toward his chest or was outside of his body as seen from the TSBD.
Bill Charleston
All these years have gone by and it never occurred to me that Connally was shot after JFK's fatal head shot. Once you're walked through it, it's immediately evident that that's exactly what happened. It all fits! It's the ONLY thing that fit's. It's amazing work. You're the VERY first person to put this all together. Congrats!! Watching your video was like putting glasses on correctly after wearing them backwards for years without realizing it. A surprised viewer
All these years have gone by and it never occurred to me that Connally was shot after JFK's fatal head shot. Once you're walked through it, it's immediately evident that that's exactly what happened. It all fits! It's the ONLY thing that fit's. It's amazing work. You're the VERY first person to put this all together. Congrats!! Watching your video was like putting glasses on correctly after wearing them backwards for years without realizing it. A surprised viewer

