Sean Murphy's research deserves more

[David Josephs]

No it doesn't, nor did the 2nd floor lunchroom encounter ever happen.

Here here Bart...

So nice to see another voice of reason out here....

And with regards to Judyth... CTKA will be posting my write-up of the main Evidence offeredand what it actually shows/says.

Now, If I can only find a beter version of these files so we can get to who that person inb the corner is...

Cheers
DJ

Sorry for the slowness. I am looking forward to reading your Judyth expose!

For those interested how it all started at the Lancer Forum, here is an archival copy, sadly no pix.

David Josephs I see you attached pix to some of the posts, I know it's a long time ago but would you remember which ones they were? Still have 'em?

http://web.archive.org/web/2007100704462...4074&page=

Hi Bart...

Yes I do remember and had created a composite of the 5 pages of Fritz's notes that I believe the 5 files refer to.

DAVID JOSEPHS WROTE:

We've talked Baker, Truly and Johnson...

what about Fritz's notes of the interrogation that say:

"Claims 2nd floor Coke when
off came in"

Was he making this up, that LHO never said this or was this well afterward when officers where gathering names of those in the building at the time?


Bookout's report on the interrogation reiterates this information and helps us understand the actual timing...

Bookout does not put Oswald in the lunchroom as do Truly/Baker and does put a COKE in his hand which Truly/Baker deny. In Baker's story, he did not ask OSWALD if he worked there, he asked Truly.

Representative BOGGS -Right. What did you say to him?
Mr. BAKER - I didn't get anything out of him. Mr. Truly had come up to my side here, and I turned to Mr. Truly and I says, "Do you know this man, does he work here?" And he said yes, and I turned immediately and went on out up the stairs.

(Note: If they were in the lunchroom and the automatic door closed behind them how was Baker able to turn and "immediately" be on the stairs without having to deal with that door?)

Bookout then has Oswald going down to eat lunch... THEN going "Outside with Bill Shelley in front" (even though it appears "Shelley" was crossed out)

Since all this occurs after-the-fact and cannot be corroborated by tape or independent 3rd party, we are left simply with the EVIDENCE and what it suggests.
To me it suggests they are lying and trying to cover for who they actually ran into on the stairs coming down from above...

DJ