The Fiasco of Spartacus

[David Josephs]

What's truly incredible are all the good researchers who continue to ignore Greg Parker's irresponsible allegations. He has blatantly accused Jack White of doctoring an Oswald photo, and no one outside of David, Jim H. and I even objected to that. I guess he is confident that none of Jack's survivors are lawsuit-happy. I'm not an attorney, but that borders on slander imho.

Robert Charles-Dunne is a supporter of Parker's, as is Sean Murphy. They are both top-notch researchers, in my view. What is it they're seeing? As I just posted on the EF, almost everything Greg posts serves to dilute the case for conspiracy. I realize he's obsessed with destroying Harvey and Lee, but to reject all the obvious Oswald impersonations, including Sylvia Odio?

I would urge Jim DiEugenio, Albert Doyle, Peter Lemkin and any other interested parties here to rejoin the EF. The management is different now, and they desperately need new voices of reason.

Don is so very right here... Is H&L that toxic to so many as is Lee & Me which gets the same type of approach yet has example after example of inauthentic evidence. Having a 15:1 AGAINST for tonsil regrowth are pretty high odds to be making definitive statments as fact.... these are not isolated incidences with no other anomolies... What does Major Gorsky have to gain by claiming Oswald was discharged in March 1959 with all his records sent to DC afterward versus the Sept 11 hardship release... for the OTHER El Toro base... the one in Santa Ana.
-----------------------------

What he does regarding the Odio evidence is Specter-like and terribly irresponsible. His argument is that the name "OSWALD" was never spoken that day. and proceeds to try and say her priest lied about her saying so to him...

Mr. LIEBELER. Did you tell Father McKann that the name Oswald was never used in your presence by any of these men?
Mrs. ODIO. Never was used e[B]xcept to introduce me, and the time when they left.[/B] They did not refer to him as Oswald.
Mr. LIEBELER. But they did in fact, introduce him as Leon Oswald?
Mrs. ODIO. And I shook hands with him.

Thank you Mr. Leibeler

He then goes on to claim that since Annie never heard "Oswald" it never happened.... I get the impression that the English language and the nuances of word meanings are lost to this man.
Words/phrases like "except", "in fact", "repreated twice", "They did not refer"

while the actual testimony is really quite obvious

And he said, "We wanted you to meet this American. His name is Leon Osw[B]ald." He repeated it twice. [/B]Then my sister Annie by that time was standing near the door. She had come to see what was going on. And they introduced him as an American who was very much interested in the Cuban cause.

So when/if Loney decides to show her stuff maybe we can get a sense of the difference between the man and the others.