18-03-2011, 05:43 PM
Albert Doyle Wrote:My point is that early on in his writings Mr Piper showed a great lack of knowlege about many elements pertaining to JFK and his emenies, for example the death of Moe Dalitz. His later efforts have been better. His opinion that Permindex was a CIA - Mossad operation may be true, but he completely ignores the Gehlen Org connections to Permindex. At the time of the JFK assassination the Permidex Board of Directors contained many Zionists, but also a few WW2 fascists. That Mossad was involved in the murder of JFK I have not doubt.Btw, Stone's JFK was outstanding, there was more truth contained in that film than in the Warren Commission Report.Kenneth Kapel Wrote:While I have no doubt that Isreal and Zionism played a kaior part in the assassintion of JFK Mr Michael Collins Piper is not a very god source.
I totally disagree. Piper is such a good source that he needs to be ignored. He's not being ignored because he made a few minor mistakes in Final Judgment. He's being ignored because he's the sole source for a hot sector of the conspiracy. If we took your logic above and applied it to Oliver Stone's JFK we could dismiss both Stone and his movie as you are doing with Piper. But it doesn't work that way however. Piper's main thesis, that you don't mention in your criticisms, is the strong CIA/Organized Crime money network associated with both Israel and conspiracy. If we compare Stone's JFK with the Warren Commission, JFK is much closer to the real conspiracy than the Warren Report. And if we compare Piper to conventional conspiracy theory, Final Judgment is the progressive cutting edge that fleshes-out the full international range of the forces involved and their influences.
Just my opinion, the Chicago mob had a bigger role in the assassination than did the Meyey Lansky group, Piper says that Ruby was a member of the Lasky organization, Ruby was a member of the Chicago outfit.