06-02-2012, 05:40 AM
Monk,
I didn't say Cinque and Fetzer had definitively solved anything. However, I think their arguments are as valid as the arguments against them. As I stated before, I didn't need Cinque's study to sway me, because I already suspected Oswald was the figure in the doorway.
My primary point is that there seems to be an incomprehensible consensus, on this forum and others, declaring that the issue has been settled, and that no sensible person doubts the figure is Lovelady. As is the case with the hole in the windshield, the identity of the Umbrella Man and several other issues, I don't believe the matter has been settled at all, and think that doubts clearly remain.
And even if I thought they were right, there is no reason to ever use the "f" word on a forum dedicated to researching important issues like this. It's not like we're arguing verbally with each other; in the heat of the moment, anyone can slip up and curse. However, there is no excuse for this when you have the time to calm down and proofread before hitting enter.
I didn't say Cinque and Fetzer had definitively solved anything. However, I think their arguments are as valid as the arguments against them. As I stated before, I didn't need Cinque's study to sway me, because I already suspected Oswald was the figure in the doorway.
My primary point is that there seems to be an incomprehensible consensus, on this forum and others, declaring that the issue has been settled, and that no sensible person doubts the figure is Lovelady. As is the case with the hole in the windshield, the identity of the Umbrella Man and several other issues, I don't believe the matter has been settled at all, and think that doubts clearly remain.
And even if I thought they were right, there is no reason to ever use the "f" word on a forum dedicated to researching important issues like this. It's not like we're arguing verbally with each other; in the heat of the moment, anyone can slip up and curse. However, there is no excuse for this when you have the time to calm down and proofread before hitting enter.

