22-03-2012, 03:19 AM
Show notes...
Dr. Mantik:
Is a practicing Medical Doctor
Is Board Certified in Radiation Oncology
Has a PhD in Physics
Became seriously interested in the assassination with Stone's movie
Performed x-ray measurements at the National Archives,
JFK Assassination Logic (McAdams 2011), How to Think Like John McAdams
Six Seconds in Dallas (Thompson 1967) touted as the best, forty years later
Overview, logic in the title, but not in the book, he does commit logical fallacies
Why he omits data, culling evidence, no citation, no rules, inconsistent
After all of the data that we have accumulated, he does seem to be stuck in the past
He seems to just regurgitate second hand evidence, no real research of his own
Do not trust eyewitnesses, except for those approved by McAdams
Elizabeth Loftus, 10 closest witnesses to the limousine, it stopped, ignored
Tippet, ejected spent cartridges, Don Thomas, three irreconcilably different opinions
Back of JFK's head, McAdams argues no damage, witnesses report the opposite
Right-rear head wound descriptions, exit wound, orange or palm sized, McClelland
The right temple/forehead, identified by witnesses to the body and to photographs
Press conference, Malcolm Kilduff pointing, Chet Huntley, George Burkley
Seth Kantor, Charles Crenshaw pointed to right hair line just above the eye socket
Robinson, near the hairline, Joe O'Donnell, Robert Knudsen photographs
Above the right eye, an entry wound, Dennis David, William Pitzer
Ed Reed, Doug Horne, Reed, Robinson, saw Humes sawing into the skull
Dr. Mantik observed a trail of apparent bullet fragments on the skull x-rays
The largest fragment at the back of the head, larger pieces go farther, from the front
At the autopsy, there was no fragment on the x-rays, children can find it
Dozens of, experts could not see the fragment that night, the Clark Panel report
Double exposing an x-ray, John Ebersole, discussion ended at the mention of fragment
Assassination Science (Fetzer et al 1998), John Fitzpatrick, a forensic radiologist
McAdams acknowledges no fact checker, Dr. Mantik thanks Millicent Cranor
Assumes 20 conspirators, 96% probability that it would get out, standard deviation
Gilbert Welch (2004), a list of bad facts in the book
Photos of back of the head, stereo viewer, paired images, hair looked flat
5x7 transparencies of JFK's back, left upper back, a small dark spot, a lighter spot
Color prints, an inconsistent set of photographs, authentic? impossible
Abnormally dark area, hair washed, no autopsy witnesses saw hair washed,
Keeping major secrets, autopsy personnel, Parkland doctors, kept their secrets
Manhattan Project, Mrs. Groves was shocked, My Lai, People of the Lie (1998)
Fingerprint and palmprint evidence, Carl Day refused to sign a statement
Fingerprint identification has come under increasing skepticism as unscientific
The provenance, a print under the wooden stock, one on the trigger guard
Dr. Mantik reviews his summary, Attention Deficit Disorder, critical thinking
Dr. Mantik also appeared on Black Op Radio shows: #453, #395, #331, #127 and #029
Greg Burnham also appeared on Black Op Radio shows: #509, #081, #037, #034 and #001
John McAdams appeared on Black Op Radio shows: #443 and #442
Dr. Mantik:
Is a practicing Medical Doctor
Is Board Certified in Radiation Oncology
Has a PhD in Physics
Became seriously interested in the assassination with Stone's movie
Performed x-ray measurements at the National Archives,
JFK Assassination Logic (McAdams 2011), How to Think Like John McAdams
Six Seconds in Dallas (Thompson 1967) touted as the best, forty years later
Overview, logic in the title, but not in the book, he does commit logical fallacies
Why he omits data, culling evidence, no citation, no rules, inconsistent
After all of the data that we have accumulated, he does seem to be stuck in the past
He seems to just regurgitate second hand evidence, no real research of his own
Do not trust eyewitnesses, except for those approved by McAdams
Elizabeth Loftus, 10 closest witnesses to the limousine, it stopped, ignored
Tippet, ejected spent cartridges, Don Thomas, three irreconcilably different opinions
Back of JFK's head, McAdams argues no damage, witnesses report the opposite
Right-rear head wound descriptions, exit wound, orange or palm sized, McClelland
The right temple/forehead, identified by witnesses to the body and to photographs
Press conference, Malcolm Kilduff pointing, Chet Huntley, George Burkley
Seth Kantor, Charles Crenshaw pointed to right hair line just above the eye socket
Robinson, near the hairline, Joe O'Donnell, Robert Knudsen photographs
Above the right eye, an entry wound, Dennis David, William Pitzer
Ed Reed, Doug Horne, Reed, Robinson, saw Humes sawing into the skull
Dr. Mantik observed a trail of apparent bullet fragments on the skull x-rays
The largest fragment at the back of the head, larger pieces go farther, from the front
At the autopsy, there was no fragment on the x-rays, children can find it
Dozens of, experts could not see the fragment that night, the Clark Panel report
Double exposing an x-ray, John Ebersole, discussion ended at the mention of fragment
Assassination Science (Fetzer et al 1998), John Fitzpatrick, a forensic radiologist
McAdams acknowledges no fact checker, Dr. Mantik thanks Millicent Cranor
Assumes 20 conspirators, 96% probability that it would get out, standard deviation
Gilbert Welch (2004), a list of bad facts in the book
Photos of back of the head, stereo viewer, paired images, hair looked flat
5x7 transparencies of JFK's back, left upper back, a small dark spot, a lighter spot
Color prints, an inconsistent set of photographs, authentic? impossible
Abnormally dark area, hair washed, no autopsy witnesses saw hair washed,
Keeping major secrets, autopsy personnel, Parkland doctors, kept their secrets
Manhattan Project, Mrs. Groves was shocked, My Lai, People of the Lie (1998)
Fingerprint and palmprint evidence, Carl Day refused to sign a statement
Fingerprint identification has come under increasing skepticism as unscientific
The provenance, a print under the wooden stock, one on the trigger guard
Dr. Mantik reviews his summary, Attention Deficit Disorder, critical thinking
Dr. Mantik also appeared on Black Op Radio shows: #453, #395, #331, #127 and #029
Greg Burnham also appeared on Black Op Radio shows: #509, #081, #037, #034 and #001
John McAdams appeared on Black Op Radio shows: #443 and #442
GO_SECURE
monk
"It is difficult to abolish prejudice in those bereft of ideas. The more hatred is superficial, the more it runs deep."
James Hepburn -- Farewell America (1968)
monk
"It is difficult to abolish prejudice in those bereft of ideas. The more hatred is superficial, the more it runs deep."
James Hepburn -- Farewell America (1968)