06-05-2015, 12:42 AM
Albert Doyle Wrote:^ I seriously suggest you take another look at the twin arrival claim. Your criticism of it is very cursory and doesn't reflect how strong a case Lifton has or nearly answer all the questions involved. There was an X-Ray technician who was carrying Kennedy's X-Rays up the stairs at Bethesda who looked out the window and saw the second ambulance pulling up to the front entrance for the second arrival. Don't forget the different coffins and body wrappings, and don't forget the visible surgery to the head that was noticed at the start of the official autopsy. Where did that come from and when was it done? And don't forget the new Air Force 1 tapes that also show coordination of a helicopter lift. By the same measure, I agree Lifton has serious issues as shown in your list, however I think he has discovered something very important with the twin arrivals.
.
It is not cursory at all. That is your spin.
There are no signatures, and the guy when interviewed did not even know if it was JFK's casket. Which is unbelievable. Plus there is the near impossible time/speed factor.
You want to bring in all this other paraphernalia which was already dealt with by Roger Feinman in his fine monograph The Signal and the Noise. Which is still the best and most devastating critique of Best Evidence ever.
If you want to debate BE fine, open up a new thread. Just count me out.
I have been exposed to Lifton at length for decades. Both at EF, and at various conferences, which he does not attend anymore nor is he invited to do so.
If you want to enlist in those ten points, go ahead and be my guest. Its all yours.