Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Dirty Politics Nicky Hager's new book
Nicky Hager, who brought us information on the ECHELON spy program, has just released a new book. It has already sold out in New Zeland bit there is a Kindle version just released.

The explosive revelations have the potential to bring down the government of New Zeland and many are hoping for such a result.

Beehive = NZ parliament building.

Quote:Early in 2014 Nicky Hager was leaked a large number of email and online conversations from Cameron Slater's Whale Oil blog.
Many of these were between Slater and his personal allies on the hard right, revealing an ugly and destructive style of politics. But there were also many communications with the prime minister's office and other Cabinet ministers in the National Government.
They show us a side of Prime Minister John Key and his government of which most New Zealanders are completely unaware. Key has constructed an easy-going and relaxed public image, declaring to the public that there's no room for negative campaigning in New Zealand.'
The reality is very different. His government has worked hand in hand with Slater and his collaborators in a sustained campaign of personal attacks against their political enemies, a deliberate but hidden strategy to avoid being held responsible for negative campaigning.
Dirty Politics continues the story that began in Hager's best-selling book The Hollow Men, investigating the way that underhand and deceptive politics poisons the political environment for everyone. If you care about integrity and ethics in politics, then this book will be disturbing but essential reading.
[Image: dp-cvr-fin.jpg?w=300&h=208]
New Zealand prime minister John Key had constructed an easy-going and relaxed public image. He began the 2014 election year by appearing at university orientation weeks, not to give speeches or debate policy, but to pose in selfies' with a crowd of students, more celebrity than politician. In rural Te Kuiti, he smiled for a beautifully composed photograph having a beer and a good yarn' with locals in a country pub, a photograph that would feature that night on his Facebook page. To the public, he was a man who stayed above the name calling and personal attacks of politics. He had declared during the 2011 election campaign there's no room for negative campaigning in New Zealand'.[SUP][i][/SUP] The reality was very different.
Key had overseen a government involved in more personal attacks and negative politics than any in living memory. Robert Muldoon, National leader in the 1970s and 1980s, is remembered for his abrasive, attacking style, but the Key government had outstripped it in the frequency and breadth of attacks, while still managing to maintain the leader's genial image. It had done this in part by using others political allies, bloggers and the news media to deliver the blows. The result was a new kind of attack politics that was rapidly changing the political environment in New Zealand. That is the subject of this book.
Dirty Politics follows my earlier book, The Hollow Men, which told the story of the National Party from 2003 to 2006 under the former leader Don Brash. This sequel describes the years of John Key's leadership between 2008 and 2014.
The Hollow Men was based on a leak of leader's office documents that revealed the internal discussions, strategy plans and secret donors behind an astonishingly cynical and manipulative plan to win the 2005 election. Brash resigned when the book was released and his successor, John Key, promised a different sort of leadership. He said he would not be using Brash's advisers and pledged to rise above the politics of personal attack', saying that was not his style.[SUP][ii][/SUP]
In fact Key immediately rehired the controversial political strategists, Crosby Textor, and the politics of personal attack intensified. The difference from earlier leaders such as Muldoon was that the government ministers did not usually front the tactics themselves. Their actions and motives could remain hidden. Thus the National government had the political advantages both of the friendly face and the attack machine. Naturally this would not work if people could see both, so considerable effort went into hiding and denying these activities.
The 2006 change in National's leadership coincided with major changes occurring in politics, the Internet and the news media. Political bloggers were moving from the margins into prominence just as news organisations were further cutting back on staff. New tactics were being imported from US politics.

The origins of this book can be traced to a political event in October 2013, when extremely personal details of Auckland mayor Len Brown's sexual affairs were published on the right-wing blog site, Whale Oil. Putting aside the rights and wrongs of Brown's personal actions, it became clear that the exposé had been arranged by his political enemies to try to push him out of office and replace him with their own mayoral candidate. It was a dirty type of politics that is not normal in this country. He was actually being attacked because of his political beliefs.
In January of the following year I travelled to Dunedin for a conference, where I met a series of people who raised their concern about Cameron Slater, the Whale Oil blogger and son of a former National Party president. One woman who had left a critical comment on the Whale Oil blog site had then faced threatening approaches to her employer about why she had made the comment from her work computer. A university academic who spoke on a panel with a visiting left-leaning MP was sent a series of heavy e-mails and had messages left on his phone advising him not to associate with the politician. He believed the messages led back to Slater. These sorts of stories were being repeated all around the country: an unpleasant experience for the individuals, which risked putting them off being involved in politics.
The third experience that persuaded me to investigate Whale Oil and the growth of attack politics was an account I heard of a meeting in a major news organisation. The point of the meeting had been to discuss Cameron Slater and whether news resources should be allocated to scrutinising his activities. According to one of the people present, however, senior staff began expressing their fears about attracting attacks from Slater on themselves and their organisation. By the end of the meeting they had decided to do nothing.
Finally, in this same period, Slater hit the news after making yet another personal attack. A young West Coast man named Judd Hall had died when the car in which he was a passenger crashed off the road. Slater copied a newspaper article onto his blog and casually headed it Feral dies in Greymouth, did world a favour'.[SUP][iii][/SUP] He was a friendly-faced young man, training for an IT diploma, and, tragically, the fourth son in the family to die in an accident. (One had been killed by a drunken driver, another had died in a fall and the third had been a victim of the 2010 Pike River mining disaster). More than any single thing Slater had written, it provoked a furious public reaction.
Slater had made a specialty of collecting personal information on other people, including with the help of those he called his hacker pals'.[SUP][iv][/SUP] In April 2012 he boasted to a friend that he had received '28 Gb of emails plus a filing cabinet of documents' about a businessman, which had been passed to him by a third party.[SUP][v][/SUP] This time, apparently as part of the angry backlash to his West Coast comments, hackers targeted him. A denial of service' attack was launched against his blog site, overloading his server and shutting down the website for three days. It appears the online attackers also gained access to his computer. Thus an insensitive comment about a car accident victim may have led to long-held secrets being revealed about Slater and his political collaborators: right up to the level of senior government ministers.
Some weeks later, out of the blue, I received a package: an 8-gigabyte USB digital storage device, the contents of which appeared to have originated from the attack on Slater's website. On the USB were thousands of documents that revealed different parts of the National Party attack politics, a subject that until then had largely been a matter of speculation and denial. This was very different from my usual sources and investigations I have not used this type of source before but I believe not a single major news organisation in the country would turn down such fascinating and important material. Supplemented by some National Party sources, it has allowed stories to be told that the public has a right to know. I had no part in obtaining the material and I cannot say anything else about its origins.
The information that arrived on the USB consisted of thousands of pages of conversations on Facebook and by e-mail between Slater and his closest political associates: Jason Ede from the prime minister's office, close friend and Cabinet minister Judith Collins, strategy consultant to National MPs Simon Lusk, Slater and Lusk's apprentice Jordan Williams, their close collaborator David Farrar and a network of right-wing bloggers. There were also PR people such as Carrick Graham. It was clear that these materials were only a fraction of Slater's documents, but they give a vivid picture of his and his colleagues' activities. The project was suddenly much wider and more important than just the Whale Oil blog.
Important issues surround the use of leaked communications. First, everyone has the right to keep their communications private and there must be a very high public interest to justify publishing them. In this case, I believe most readers will agree that the materials raise very serious matters of political accountability, relating directly to the prime minister and other senior government ministers. They show a continuous collaboration between the prime minister's office, bloggers and sympathetic media to arrange attacks on National's opponents and to influence elections. This differs from the story and face presented by the National Party to the public and helps to explain much about what is wrong with contemporary politics. On the other hand, there was also a considerable amount of very personal information about relationships and other subjects, where the right to privacy outweighs any public interest. This material has not been included in the book and will not be passed to others. The fact that Slater and his associates have made a career of exposing the very private details of other people's lives does not make it right to do that to them.
The chapters that follow will describe the origins and then the many facets of the covert attack machine run by the National Party and its allies. They include persistent attacks on Labour Party politicians, attacks that consciously set out to distract, wear down or demoralise them rather than trying to debate issues or win a political argument; orchestrated attacks on potential coalition partners; repeated searches for sexual scandal and other dirt' to use for political purposes; and supposedly independent issue' campaigns actually run by National Party figures to advance the party's interests. Within the party there was concerted manipulation of National's candidate selection processes.
The attacks are heightened by the routine use of extreme and mocking language. Environmentalists are green Taliban. Almost everyone on the left of politics is a liar and a hypocrite. An environment is created and encouraged where anonymous commenters on blogs and news sites join in the attacks, competing with each other in abuse and ugly personal insults. It is more like political warfare than a debate of ideas and beliefs.
The book begins by setting the scene and introducing the bloggers who became a political force only after the period covered by The Hollow Men. Then the serious material begins: the continuous close ties between the prime minister's office and the attack dogs, the role of Judith Collins and the inside story of the political issues and campaigns that they manipulated layer upon layer of hidden activities and dirty politics.
The main beneficiaries of the political attacks are the National Party and its senior politicians. This does not mean, as has been speculated, that Slater and the others were all secretly on the National Party payroll. The reality is more complicated. There are factions and tensions. John Key is very close to Farrar but does not and cannot control Slater. But when it comes to smears against Labour and other political opponents, the government and the attack bloggers do work together, with Ede as the primary conduit. When I write about National Party attack politics, readers will see that some attacks are collaborations with the prime minister's office and the National Party, and some are with different parts of the Beehive, reflecting National's deep factions. Sometimes political allies such as Slater and Farrar understand perfectly well what is in the party's interests and do not need to be asked. But overall these activities systematically promote the interests of the party leadership, who are aware of and closely involved in many of the operations.
The prime minister appears in the early chapters mainly through the work of his senior staffer, Jason Ede. But by 2014, later in the book, it is clear there are regular communications between John Key and Slater.
It should not be a surprise that the negative politics documented in this book occurred under a government run by John Key, Steven Joyce and other colleagues, many of whom featured in The Hollow Men. With Key, the relaxed and smiling image had always been artifice, as anyone who had seen his face when he was displeased knew. But the image had worked well through his eight years as leader. For them, the systematic use of attack politics has been a dangerous secret, something National knew would look bad to the public and thus a political risk. But the short-term political gains were too tempting and it has continued year after year.
I wrote in the preface to The Hollow Men:
The underlying theme of the book is the conduct of politicians and others in politics how their strategies, expediencies and the games they play to advance themselves can harm the whole political system. Short-term political necessities get in the way of the long-term good of the country. The [book] shows how easy it is to spin and manipulate and how our defences as a society (news media, electoral laws and so on) are inadequate to protect the public. This in turn creates the situation where many people don't like politics' and leave it to the politicians and if anything is clear from this story it is that politics should not be left to the politicians. The story is, in essence, about democracy that ideal everyone in politics applauds and few respect.
These are the underlying ideas of this book too. Like the cynical advisers seen in The Hollow Men, the people described in these pages have helped to create a type of politics that disappoints and repels many ordinary people. But the book is not about the inevitability of expedient and unprincipled politics. Understanding what is wrong means things do not have to remain that way, and exposing dirty politics is an essential step in allowing reasonable people to understand and to choose other approaches. There is no need to follow those who are least principled down into the pit.

Nicky Hager
August 2014
[SUP][i][/SUP] Amelia Romanos, Greens billboard vandal quits',
[SUP][ii][/SUP] Tracy Watkins, Dominion Post, Key: I believe in an inclusive New Zealand', 28 November 2006.
[SUP][iii][/SUP] Cameron Slater, Whale Oil blog, Feral dies in Greymouth, did world a favour', 25 January 2014.
[SUP][iv][/SUP] Cameron Slater, Facebook private messaging to Aaron Bhatnagar, 5 October 2011.
[SUP][v][/SUP] Jonathan Marshall, Facebook private messaging to Cameron Slater, 30 April 2012. Slater wrote to his journalist friend, Jonathan Marshall, I have a massive story this week, gonna run for days.' What is it?' Marshall asked. Three journos will be casualties,' Slater said, fraud, sfo [Serious Fraud Office], fma [Financial Markets Authority] … rat fink directors, dodgy transactions, I've got 28Gb of emails, plus a filing cabinet of documents.' Marshall said, niccce.' Slater said he had three journos putting their names to articles written by the fraudster…. 2 ex NBR and one Herald…. [and] two lawyers who will go down plus a liquidator.' Slater was subsequently sued by the man concerned, Matthew Blomfield.
"The philosophers have only interpreted the world, in various ways. The point, however, is to change it." Karl Marx

"He would, wouldn't he?" Mandy Rice-Davies. When asked in court whether she knew that Lord Astor had denied having sex with her.

“I think it would be a good idea” Ghandi, when asked about Western Civilisation.

Hacked emails revealed online

[TD="align: left"][/TD]

[TD="align: left"][/TD]



Dirty politics - is there any other kind? Beehive Live: Celebrating in Ngaruawahia Response to Dirty Politics 'surreal' - lawyer Still to be seen if Brand Key tarnished Key's veneer of good humour wears thin Today in politics: Tuesday, August 19 Student leader 'revolted' by politics Hager's book empowers Venice-bound artist Economy okay but fine tuning a good idea Fiji police investigate high seas shooting video [Image: icon_video.gif]
A website claiming to have access to Cameron Slater's hacked emails has released images suggesting the Whale Oil blogger had advice on Official Information Act requests from former Beehive staffer Jason Ede.
This afternoon the @WhaleDump Twitter account linked to a zipfile on the website which contained 12 files that appear to be screengrabs of emails sent to and from Slater's gmail account.
The files include emails from, which according to a screengrab - which appears to be of Slater's contact book - is from a Jason Ede.
Ede is the former staffer in John Key's office, believed to still have swipe card access to the Beehive, implicated in Nicky Hager's book Dirty Politics as being an arm's length link to right wing blogs WhaleOil and Kiwiblog, used to attack opponents. The @whaledump Twitter account is thought to be the same as the source which Hager based his book on.
"The OIA would be to the Department, seeking "salary bands" including total remuneration packages for MFat staffers based overseas. Needs to include a request for a list of all staff allowances," an email from political.animal101 sent on March 6, 2008 states.
> Share this story on Facebook.
Slater has denied getting OIA advice from Ede or even getting emails from him. Ede now works for the National Party.
"I don't think I've ever received an email from Jason Ede detailing OIA requests," Slater said last week.
"In fact, the Government put pressure on me - quite significant pressure from numerous senior people, including ministers - to withdraw my OIA request about the SIS and the Phil Goff situation because they felt that it was going to give them some pushback that they didn't want."
Another screengrab is of an email sent from Key's former chief press secretary Kevin Taylor to Slater.
In the email dated 28 May, 2008 Taylor responds to a request from Slater to do a video interview with Key for his blog.
Taylor declines, saying if they started engaging with blogs they would have to engage with them all. He added however that "FYI Jason Ede asked me to mention that he will be giving you a call in the next few days".
Most of the emails released today were alluded to in the new book by Hager, which was released last week, however the full text of the emails was not included.
The book claims that National's strategy was to protect the friendly brand of John Key, while using right wing blogs as a vehicle to attack opponents.
In another series of emails, Ede forwards an email from his Parliamentary address to a hotmail address,
This email address later emailed Slater offering "a hearty sigh of relief" for dynamic IP addresses. This quote was a key element of Hager's book relating to claims that Ede accessed parts of the Labour Party website which contained details of its donors.
The same email address then emails Slater calling for his support on a strategy to attack Labour if the opposition was to attack it on the cost of the Botany by-election in 2011, won by National's Jami-Lee Ross.
"If Labour go after Ross on the cost of a by-election - I do hope I can count on you to run some interference on Wood's local board position?" NZ Jed wrote on January 27 2011.
NZ Jed wrote they were "seeking advice" on whether the Labour candidate, a local board member, would force a by-election if elected and how much that would cost.
"If it sticks, Labour cannot run the cost argument," NZ Jed wrote.
Slater responds: "I have a strategy to smack Labour on that... I've run it before and will run it again."
The email also shows Slater was angry at National Party president Peter Goodfellow, saying "for now I need to get my mate elected, but I won't be forgetting anytime soon the actions of tonight".
The comment appears to related to Slater being shut out of a National Party meeting.
Hager said he had not seen the Twitter account and had not heard from his source about their intention to release the information.
"I am not certain who is behind [the account]... I think it is likely that this will be my source responding to the request that came to release the material."
Hager said he had spoken with his source at the weekend to try to get some of the information back in order to release it "and they said: 'Leave this to me'".
"It sounded like they were going to do something but I didn't have any more detail."
He welcomed the dump.
"I know that I faithfully, and as fairly as I could, reported in the book, but people can check that out for themselves if it does come out."
Hager also said he remained confident his source was not politically motivated.
Slater had earlier written on his blog that "this was always going to happen".
"My guess is hacker wants the attention[,] the credit and limelight but will be careful not to reveal their identity/employer."
Slater said it was "awfully convenient" that the people behind the Twitter account were aligning themselves with hackers collective Anonymous, WikiLeaks and Kim Dotcom's file-sharing website Mega.
This is going to get tense," Slater said.
"People with much more to lose than I do will now fall in behind me and others who don't break the law to hunt down everyone involved with this. Poor Nicky Hager. He's really been minced here."
Another email responded to Slater's WhaleOil request for information on November 15, 2011, on the owners of two motorbikes which were sighted after National Party billboards were defaced.
A man called Robert Ridley emailed saying one belonged to Jolyon White, which the screenshots show Slater forwarded to "Jason", and later posted on WhaleOil.
White was a partner of Green Party co-leader Russel Norman's executive assistant. The same day, Norman admitted vandalism of more than 700 National Party billboard was co-ordinated by White, but said it was not related to the Green Party.
Prime Minister John Key said he had not seen the emails and would not be seeking them out.
He loosely linked the emails to Internet Party founder Kim Dotcom, saying it was "spooky" they had been released on Dotcom's file sharing site,
Key repeated comments it was a 'left-wing conspiracy".
"You see a one-sided picture. There are lots of times where people have discussions about information. The mainstream media does that all the time."
Key dismissed questions on whether it was appropriate for staffer Jason Ede to advise Slater on how to word Official Information requests.
"No, that's one side of a version of events like a lot of things. And that's the problem actually, it's one of the reasons why a lot of the stories here are dissolving.
"Mr Hager himself through this whole process has now had to admit that readers got things wrong, there's been so many stories that have actually been contested and dissolved before his eyes.
"You've got a left-wing conspiracy and a whole bunch of people who are trying to discredit the Government," he said.
"I think New Zealanders will be far more interested frankly in urban cycleways than the back and forth of what [media] are talking about.
"But at the end of the day let's just remember what's happening. This is a slanted, one-sided perspective of what's going on."
- Stuff
"The philosophers have only interpreted the world, in various ways. The point, however, is to change it." Karl Marx

"He would, wouldn't he?" Mandy Rice-Davies. When asked in court whether she knew that Lord Astor had denied having sex with her.

“I think it would be a good idea” Ghandi, when asked about Western Civilisation.
A dangerous precedent and a threat to journalism.

Quote:Investigative journalist Nicky Hager's been the target of a police raid as they try to flush out the hacker who downloaded Whale Oil blogger Cameron Slater's e-mails.

A police spokesperson confirmed computers and "related items" were taken from Mr Hager's Roseneath home as part of its ongoing investigation into the alleged hacking.
Emails and Facebook messages between Slater and his associates formed the backbone of Mr Hager's book Dirty Politics.
It exposed smear tactics and created a furore ahead of the election.
Police are investigating the hacker Rawshark they want to know who he is.
It is understood the raid on Mr Hager is an attempt to flush hum out.
Mr Hager says he is in talks with his lawyer about the incident about ways to challenge the police actions.
He said police went to his home while he was in lecturing in Auckland on October 2.
Five police officers arrived early in the morning with a search warrant and spent more than 10 hours searching the property.
Mr Hager said he spoke to the officer over the phone, who told him he was a witness in the case, rather than a suspect.

"Nonetheless, he and his four colleagues seized a large collection of papers and electronic equipment belonging to my family, including computers, drives, phones, CDs, an Ipod and a camera," he said.
He is confident police took nothing which would help them with their investigation and called it "pointless".

"Their actions were a fishing expedition. There was nothing in the house even faintly related to my sources."
Mr Hager told 3 News it was "unsettling" to have his house searched, but police were "reasonably polite" about it given the circumstances.
"This is an extremely heavy-handed way for the police to go about the case and I think it's purely because they were getting nowhere with the case and if they came into my house it would help them, but it won't."
While working on the book, Mr Hager said he was prepared for a raid-type situation, but did not believe the police would conduct one on his property.
He is adamant he has not done anything illegal.
"I believe the police actions are dangerous for journalism in New Zealand. It matters to all people working in the media who could similarly have their property searched and seized to look for sources."
Mr Hager said police had not spoken to him since the raid and he would not cooperate if and when they did.
Police want anyone with relevant information to come forward or contact CrimeStoppers anonymously.
"The philosophers have only interpreted the world, in various ways. The point, however, is to change it." Karl Marx

"He would, wouldn't he?" Mandy Rice-Davies. When asked in court whether she knew that Lord Astor had denied having sex with her.

“I think it would be a good idea” Ghandi, when asked about Western Civilisation.

Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  My "Surviveandheal15" 10-Book Recommended Reading List George Williams 0 2,026 24-01-2021, 09:41 PM
Last Post: George Williams
  Book search // The Garrison enquiry: Truth & consequences: Joachim Joesten Alex Cruceru 3 10,289 31-07-2018, 07:19 PM
Last Post: Peter Lemkin
  OMINOUS POLITICS by John Saloma Anthony Thorne 0 6,779 24-07-2018, 06:47 AM
Last Post: Anthony Thorne
  New Book On JFK and Who QJ/WIN might have been Peter Lemkin 9 19,693 04-01-2018, 03:27 PM
Last Post: Peter Lemkin
  Given the author, I will certainly look into this book... Peter Lemkin 2 15,610 09-07-2017, 02:01 AM
Last Post: Lauren Johnson
  Doug Valentine's New Book - CIA as Organized Crime Peter Lemkin 3 19,527 24-01-2017, 06:04 PM
Last Post: Lauren Johnson
  Walter Bowart's book "Operation Mind Control - The Cryptocracy's Plan to Psychocivlise You" Magda Hassan 25 29,536 28-05-2016, 07:47 AM
Last Post: Mark A. O'Blazney
  Announcing the DPF Book List Myra Bronstein 15 53,978 30-05-2014, 06:16 AM
Last Post: Peter Lemkin
  New book on dc madam case Magda Hassan 8 7,837 26-11-2013, 11:29 AM
Last Post: Magda Hassan
  Book; Cheny and Bush; ; Differ on 911. Iraq Bernice Moore 0 2,583 01-09-2011, 05:27 AM
Last Post: Bernice Moore

Forum Jump:

Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)