Sean Murphy's research deserves more

[Bob Prudhomme]

Albert, are you aware that the 1st floor lunch room where Oswald often ate lunch, known as the Domino Room, was not the same as the lunch room on the 2nd floor? Are you also aware that the evidence points strongly toward the 2nd floor encounter between Oswald, Truly and Baker being a fabrication?

If Oswald had been in the 1st floor lunch room, what would be so difficult about his stepping outside at the last moment before JFK arrived? The TSBD is not that big of a building. Do you think it would take more than 30 seconds to go from the 1st floor lunch room to the front steps?

I already answered that but you ignored it. To say what you are saying would require Carolyn Arnold to be a liar. I don't think she was a liar. In my mind FBI's desperate need to alter Carolyn Arnold's time to 12:15 is a strong sign they were trying to cover-up something they knew was true. We're right back to where we were before. In my mind it is much more likely Oswald was in the 2nd floor lunchroom from 12:25 to 12:31:30 than making this huge trip and being on the front steps in the wide open without being seen. Also, I think your claim that there's strong evidence the Baker/Oswald encounter was fabricated is based mainly on your affidavit argument which I showed could have had many other reasonable explanations that you ignored.

Bob, how do you explain your Oswald Prayer Man milling about with the people in the front door during the Baker entry and not being seen?

Arnold maintained she saw Oswald closer to 12:25 on the 1st floor. If he ate his lunch on the 1st floor, he had plenty of time to go to the Coke machine on the 2nd floor, buy a Coke, return to the 1st floor and check out what all the excitement was outside; well before the motorcade arrived at 12:30. Remember, the stairs to the 2nd floor were close to the front entrance of the TSBD. She could have seen him going to or returning from the 2nd floor. One sighting at 12:25 does not place him on the 2nd floor for an extended period of time.

I would explain it the same way I would explain how Baker, in full uniform and a white helmet, ran past Frazier and Frazier has no recollection of it. Judging by where Frazier is seen standing, Baker likely had to push him out of the way, but Frazier draws a total blank on seeing Baker. A good term for it might be "induced amnesia". Also, if Oswald appeared at the last second, those people in front of him would have their full attention on the motorcade.