Sean Murphy's research deserves more

[David Josephs]

That's a question that you will never get answered Bob. Never. Three times he mentions his affidavit during his testimony and three times they ignore it and move on. Baker's testimony is from March 20th while Truly was the next week.... BELIN was most certainly aware of Baker's affidavit yet lets Truly do his little dance:



What can't be argued is what the physical evidence offered says... the affidavit and the obvious conflict with the entire lunchroom scene. I know I sound like a broken record but if Armstrong is right, it may have been Lee coming down the stairs and Harvey in the lunchroom... yet then we get the story from Mrs Reid about Oswald in only a T-shirt - so it would have to be LEE who leaves that way.

If I could respond to what was addressed to Bob - this is what I'm trying to say, is the pressure about seeing two Oswald's would create the need to leave one out and fit the pattern of conflicts in the evidence. They are aware there is a problem and working around it. Truly was the Potemkin minder. If you were going to omit one Oswald it would be the one that was further away.


It fits doesn't it?


And don't forget Carolyn Arnold places Oswald in the lunchroom at 12:25 - making it more likely he was there the whole time.

Albert - Carolyn places him walking past the front doors on the inside at 12:25... not the lunchroom.

And it would make more sense to place Oswald CLOSER to the 6th floor, not farther away, giving the timing. Walking down the stairs 1-2 flights up is much more incriminating thatn in the lunchroom with the mechanical door closed with a coke in his hand... so they at least tried to lose the Coke... but the man on the stairs in the affidavit is completely eliminated from consideration.

If Prayerman is HARVEY, which is looking more and more likely, the lunchroom thing NEVER HAPPENED and the man in the stairs was indeed LEE.
the lunchroom scene is created to get Oswald from the Prayerman location - and it being impossible he was on the 6th floor, at least in the building. Mrs Reid sees LEE. Craig sees Harvey get into the car since we also know the McWatters bustrip was fabricated as well.