08-03-2017, 02:10 AM
Bob Prudhomme Wrote:You're not reading Shelley's statement very closely, Albert, which somehow does not surprise me.
He says "I ran across the street to the corner of the park and ran into a girl crying......".
He is neither 1) across the street yet, as the two men are in the middle of the street or 2) at the corner of the park, as the man in the film is still beside the concrete island.
Running Woman is 1) on the opposite side of the street from the concrete island and 2) well past the corner of the park before "Shelley" even gets close to it.
Your fantasy will not work unless you are willing to state Bill Shelley lied in his first day statement.
https://texashistory.unt.edu/ark:/67531/...7377/m1/1/
You're not addressing the full context of this Bob. We know from the Dunkel Film that Shelley and Lovelady did a lot more than what was mentioned in your linked affidavit. When viewed in its correct condensed context the statement is contracting Shelley's running to the island and then walking up the Extension into one sentence. Your interpretation is trying to force Shelley's meeting Calvery to the island but we know that didn't happen by simply looking at the Dunkel Film that clearly shows Shelley encountering Calvery as he walks up the Extension.
If you correctly interpreted what you are analyzing you would realize the timing of the Dunkel Film allows Shelley to jut out to the island and then head up the Elm St Extension where he meets Calvery. I am still having trouble understanding what problem you are having with the Dunkel Film that shows exactly this. It shows Shelley pulling up in order to hear what Calvery is saying. The woman is 100% Calvery because she fits every single witness statement and also locks right in to Molina's timing.
Bob, the film shows Shelley encountering Calvery on the Elm St Extension. This is the reality and also the means by which to calibrate the statements and evidence. It also does not preclude Shelley going to the island first, nor does it mean he is lying in his affidavit.
What's bizarre about this is the unknown woman who came in with Calvery to the lobby, as witnessed by Molina, could very well be Sarah Stanton (Prayer Man).