Karl - I agree that a big dose of authentication MUST be expected with a theory such as this...
I ask that you look at the following and ask yourself what exactly is going on...
This is a ship manifest taking me from Ping-Tung Taiwan back to Atsugi on October 6th... Lee H OSWALD is on this ship.
Next to it is the Sept 14th manifest when they LEFT from Atsugi for Taiwan... once again Lee H OSWALD is on this ship
Under that is a letter illustrating the conflict... and next to that the health records summary starting with September 16th while one of the Oswald's is at sea
Based on the DoD records from the Navy Oswald was in both Japan and Taiwan during his tour of duty... this is repeated in numerous "reports" and documents....
the ONLY time Oswald is said to be in Taiwan is during this time... Yet other DoD documents claim he stayed behind...
Finally, at the bottom - in classic FBI document preservation mode - is a FBI interview with a man who knew Oswald, knew he was taken to the ship to Taiwan (in bare feet and guarded)
says he saw little of Oswald while in Taiwan ("little" is not, not at all) and heard stories the fit Oswald exactly...
Karl - I'm good with there being a SLIGHT mistake about Oswald leaving Japan.... but his being on the return ship's Unit Diary... when he is supposedly being treated continuosly for STD in Japan
seems a bit much even for coincidence.
I also notice you do not address ANY of the images or testimonies I referenced... I'm not in this for a tit-for-tat discussion with you and you are entitled to you opinion based on the evidence you are aware of...
Robert doesn't just pull this out of thin air Karl.... and as with any theory about a clandestine operation -
Don't you suppose the entire idea is to make the left behind evidence of such a operation as ambiguous as possible - if any evidence is to be left behind at all? That you expect a side-by-side photo of Lee and Harvey both holding up a newspaper from that day is somewhat unrealistic, don't you think?
I've done so many comarison images and overlays of Lee and Harvey as to render the argument against virtually moot... Now, if you would, go to these exhibits and see that in every single case John Edward picks Lee from Harvey... and when asked about Thanksgiving 1962 he refers to the person as the man that "
appears to be Lee Harvey Oswald in 1962"... not exactly a brother identifying his brother....
==========
Mr. JENNER - I show you an exhibit, a series of exhibits, first Commission Exhibit No. 281 and Exhibit No. 282 being some spread pages of an issue of Life magazine of February 21, 1964. I direct your attention first to the lower lefthand spread at .the bottom of the page. Do you recognize the area shown there?
Mr. PIC - No, sir.
Mr. JENNER - Do you see somebody in that picture that appears to be your brother?
Mr. PIC - This one here with the arrow.
Mr. JENNER - The one that has the printed arrow?
Mr. PIC - That is correct, sir.
Mr. JENNER - And you recognize that as your brother?
Mr. PIC - Because they say so, sir.
Mr. JENNER - Please, I don't want you to say--
Mr. PIC - No; I couldn't recognize that.
Mr. JENNER - Because this magazine says that it is.
Mr. PIC - No, sir; I couldn't recognize him from that picture.
Mr. JENNER - You don't recognize anybody else in the picture after studying it that appears to be your brother? When I say your brother now, I am talking about Lee.
Mr. PIC - No, sir.
Mr. JENNER - In the upper portion there are a series of photographs spread from left-hand page across to the right-hand page. Take those on the left which appears to be a photograph of three young men. Do you recognize the persons shown in that photograph?
Mr. PIC - Yes; I recognize ,this photograph, the people from left to right being Robert Oswald, the center one being Lee Oswald, and the third one being myself. This picture was taken at the house in Dallas when we returned from New Orleans.
Mr. JENNER - You mean from--when you came from New Orleans after being at the Bethlehem Orphanage Home?
Mr. PIC - Yes, sir.
Mr. JENNER - And you went to Dallas?
Mr. PIC - Yes, sir.
Mr. JENNER - It was taken in Dallas at or about that time?
Mr. PIC - Yes, sir.
Mr. JENNER - The next one is prominent; in front is a picture of a young boy. There is a partially shown girl and apparently another boy with a striped shirt in the background. Do you recognize that picture?
Mr. PIC - Yes; I recognize that as Lee Harvey Oswald.
Mr. JENNER - Do you have any impression as to when and where that was taken?
Mr. PIC - Just looking at the picture, I would guess first, second grade, maybe. I would have to guess at it.
Mr. JENNER - Then there is one immediately to the right of that, a young man in the foreground sitting on the floor, with his knees, legs crossed, and his arms also crossed. There are some other people apparently in the background.
Mr. PIC - I recognize that as Lee Harvey Oswald.
Mr. JENNER - Does anything about the picture enable you to identify as to where that was taken?
Mr. PIC - No, sir.
Mr. JENNER - Then to the right there is a picture of two young men, the upper portion of the one young man at the bottom and then apparently a young man standing up in back of that person. Do you recognize either of those young people?
Mr. PIC - Yes; I recognize Lee Harvey Oswald.
Mr. JENNER - Is he the one to which the black arrow is pointing?
Mr. PIC - Yes, sir.
Mr. JENNER - Then right below that is a picture of a young man standing in front of an iron fence, which appears to be probably at a zoo. Do you recognize that?
Mr. PIC - Sir, from that picture, I could not recognize that that is Lee Harvey Oswald.
Mr. JENNER - That young fellow is shown there, he doesn't look like you recall Lee looked in 1952 and 1953 when you saw him in New York City?
Mr. PIC - No, sir.
Mr. JENNER -
Commission Exhibit No. 284 do you recognize anybody in that picture that appears to be Lee Oswald?
(DJ: THIS IS THE CLASSROOM PHOTO)
Mr. PIC - No, sir.
Mr. JENNER - There is a young fellow in the foreground-everybody else is facing the other way. He is in a pantomime, or grimace. Do you recognize that as Lee Harvey Oswald?
Mr. PIC - No, sir; looking at that picture and I have looked at it several times--that looks more like Robert than it does Lee, to my recollection.
Mr. JENNER - All right. On Exhibit No. 286, the lower right-hand corner, there is another picture. Do you recognize that as your brother Lee in that picture?
Mr. PIC - Yes, sir; that is about how he looked when I seen him in 1962, his profile.
Mr. JENNER - Do you recognize the person, the lady to the right who is pointing her finger at him?
Mr. PIC - No, sir; I don't.
Mr. JENNER - Exhibit No. 287 is two figures, taking them from top to bottom and in the lower right-hand corner, do you recognize those?
Mr. PIC - No, sir; I don't.
Mr. JENNER - Neither one of them?
Mr. PIC - No, sir. The lower one appears to me to look like Robert rather than Lee. The upper one, unless they tell me that, I would never guess that that would be Lee, sir.
Mr. JENNER - All right. Exhibit No. 288, there is ill the lower left-hand corner, there is a reproduction of a service card and a reproduction, also, of a photograph with the head of a man. Do you recognize that?
Mr. PIC - That looks to me approximately how Lee Oswald looked when I seen him Thanksgiving 1962.
Mr. JENNER - Directing your attention to Exhibit, Commission Exhibit No. 289, do you recognize any of the servicemen shown in that picture as your brother Lee?
Mr. PIC - No, sir; I do not recognize them.
Mr. JENNER - Exhibit No. 290, the lower left-hand corner there is a photograph of a young lady and a young man. Do you recognize either of those persons?
Mr. PIC - He appears to me as Lee Harvey Oswald in 1962 when I seen him.
Mr. JENNER - And the lady?
Mr. PIC - She is his wife, Marina, sir.
Mr. JENNER - Commission Exhibit No. 291, at the bottom of the page, there is a picture of a young man handing out a leaflet, and another man to the left of him who is reaching out for it. Do you recognize the young man handing out the leaflet?
Mr. PIC - No, sir; I would be unable to recognize him.
Mr. JENNER - As to whether he was your brother?
Mr. PIC - That is correct.
http://www.aarclibrary.org/publib/jfk/wc..._0413a.htm
[ATTACH=CONFIG]5074[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]5075[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH=CONFIG]5076[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]5077[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH=CONFIG]5078[/ATTACH]