Sean Murphy's research deserves more

[Albert Doyle]

I think this is accurate about this imbroglio. It becomes a Rohrsach test with images that degraded.

If you look at Duncan's arrow photo Prayer Man is visible enough to see the dark hair tones. Those tones are clearly hair and can't be anything else. They extend down to the neck. This is a correct scientific argument of evidence that deserves respect. I suggest ignoring it or blowing it off with offhand comments comes at the expense of credibility.



Jim, what is the dark notch near the wrist area on Prayer Man's right forearm? It has to be something because it is blocking the arm. What is it? This is a legitimate photographic science issue that is above the degraded image and pixel excuses that are being used to ignore it.


Are Prayer Man's arms crossed? What is your opinion on that Jim? Too blurry to tell? You seem to have no such degraded image problem when Sean Murphy used the same images.


These are perfectly fair questions that deserve answers. Is there a CTKA conflict of interest here for a host author?



.