03-01-2012, 07:07 PM
Dr Ralph Cinque Wrote:My position is that when I point to likenesses between Doorman's shirt and Oswald's that cannot be accounted for by chance alone, it is obfuscating to raise other questions, such as the ones you raise.
Nonsense. The questions I raise are relevant to and have a direct bearing on the ultimate value of your position -- which does not exist in some sort of isolation zone. Your deep political analysis skills are seemingly non-existent. And no matter how hard you try to direct responses to your posts along the lines you favor, you have no authority -- intellectual or otherwise -- to do so.
Dr Ralph Cinque Wrote:When I said the deep political analysis has nothing to do with it I meant that politcal analysis, deep or otherwise, has nothing to do with it. Politics has nothing to do with it. We are talking about physical evidence here -not political analysis. I am not asking people to look at it with a deep political perspective. I am asking people to look at it with two open eyes.
Nonsense. You are asking people to look at your "argument" with one myopic eye.
You cannot even define "deep politics," so how can you have even the foggiest idea as to the merits of deep political analysis to the Altgens 6 question?
How the hell can we analyze successfully ANY aspect of the JFK case except from a deep political perspective?
Dr Ralph Cinque Wrote:Altgens photo was in the hands of the AP. They owned it. Altgens worked for them. And they made it available to newspapers. What is vague about that?
EVERYTHING! And if you honestly believe otherwise, then you're over your head on this forum.
Dr Ralph Cinque Wrote:You haven't responded to the likenesses that I pointed to- and whether those likenesses occurred by chance or otherwise. And if you are going to cling to the Lovelady hypothesis, then you have to wrestle with the odds that Oswald and Lovelady both dressed so similarly that day.
I have responded DIRECTLY and REPEATEDLY to your "argument." As for my position on the Lovelady/Oswald/Altgens 6 issue -- you haven't the foggiest idea, have you? And yet the vast majority of the readers of this exchange have a very clear idea of where I stand.
Best to the girl in the closet.