Opinions on Roscoe White story?

[David Josephs]

Okay. I am going to FORCE this thread back on track, and I am making no apologies for covering "previously unmentioned" material.
I was not aware (and see no statement in the rules) that original investigative discussion in not allowed here, so if anyone has any on topic related replies, please make them.

DAVID JOSEPHS,
was it not you who stepped up to claim the authorship of the previously sited thread from the Education forum containing a discussion of the police officer at the rear of the Landsdale photograph here.

CAN YOU PLEASE REITERATE HERE YOUR CONCLUSION.
Is it or is it not your opinion that the below pictured police officer IS NOT ACCURATELY ACCOUNTED FOR in the record?
Can you reiterate and rejustify this claim?

If it is so that the below pictured officer is not who the records say he should be,
does it not ON THE FACE OF IT appear that it could be Roscoe White? (this is open to anyone, not just David)
The image of Roscoe in his police uniform (on the right below) bares (to me at least) significantly more than a superficial resemblance.
[ATTACH=CONFIG]5661[/ATTACH]

I would like to note that I am making this post IN THE SPIRIT OF GENUINE INQUIRY.
I am specifically asking that unjustified attacks be withheld so that legitimate inquiry can take place.
I am NOT saying this IS Roscoe White ... i am, again, MERELY PRESENTING IT FOR EARNEST DISCUSSION.
If my reading of Mr. Joseph is correct, and IF HE IS TO CONFIRM THIS, then if the above pictured officer is NOT who the records claim,
it must be SOMEONE ELSE. All things considered, it looks to me a LOT like Roscoe White. Hence, I would ask for a discussion on the merits of this claim.

Hey there Nick... I'm with you here and will continue to focus on discussion of the evidence and the topics of your interest... All you can do is stay on your own course... the truth of the situaiton will shake out.


Wasn't actually "claimed"... I started/authored the thread and presented my understanding as to why there were two sets of tramps... those in these photos and those who were arrested and spent a few days in jail to be let out 11/26.

MARVIN WISE identifies himself as the policeman in the back of the Lansdale photo... yet he does seem to disappear as they get to Houston... in the Allen photos....
http://jfkassassinationfiles.com/fbi_124-10273-10440 According to Wise we have Bass, Harkness, Middleton and Vaughn...
Middleton claims to have been home that day and not involved at all http://jfkassassinationfiles.com/fbi_124-10273-10392
Harkness says there were others taken from THE TRAIN (below)
Vaughn does not have a statement related to the RR yard, tramps or any of it - only the Oswald murder


In answer to your question - if the man in the photos is Wise, then I think these two men are both Wise... if it is someone else, then they are both this person... and they are not Roscoe White... imo.


[ATTACH=CONFIG]5668[/ATTACH]





[ATTACH=CONFIG]5664[/ATTACH]