10-01-2014, 11:30 PM
David Josephs Wrote:yet speaking of those STUBBY FINGERS... in WCD 443we are offered a collection of photos which Marina is asked to ID....
They are seperated into "ITEMS" and this is ITEM #4 with Marina's description...
If Photo #3 was taken by Oswald and in HIS possession... would that not suppose there was a closer relationship between OSWALD and WHITE than previously suggested?
And that HARVEY used a photo of Roscoe when he created the BYP, if HE created them?
If not, what is OSWALD doing with a photo of his "Marine Corps friends in Japan" including one Roscoe White?
[ATTACH=CONFIG]5639[/ATTACH]
Okay. So I am just going to ignore all the paranoid ass holes on this board (since there seem to be an unfortunate majority), and focus on the few people who actually seem to have something intelligent to contribute. THANK YOU DAVID FOR BRINGING SOMETHING TO DISCUSS other than the notion that i may or may not "suck", be a "shmuck" or be paranoid that you guys are paranoid (?huh?) ...
***I TOO FIND IT HIGHLY INTRIGUING THAT A PHOTOGRAPH OF ROSCOE WHITE WAS ENTERED IN TO WARREN COMMISSION EVIDENCE IN A GROUP OF PHOTOGRAPHS ALL CLEARLY TAKEN BY OSWALD***
Here is the link you provided in your Education forum post to Marry Ferrell's site, showing that inventory of photographs, so no mistake can be made, these photos were entered in to Warren Commission evidence, and positively ID'd by Marina as "friends of Oswald in Japan".
http://www.maryferrell.org/mffweb/archiv...elPageId=4
And this guy just magically resurfaces in the DPD two months before 11\22\63 ???
hmm.
My other few comments for the moment:
a. Roscoe's Gut -- while I was a little hesitant in comparing the WCD443 Roscoe White photograph with the BYP, given that White clearly seems to have somewhat of a gut in the beach photo ... I have actually become less concerned with this fact after studying the BYP photo with this "discrepancy" in mind and noticing that if you look just below the paper in his hand, it seems rather much like the person DOES in deed have a gut, and that quite simply (as any woman worth a salt knows) the all black attire conceals this weight rather well.
b. Roscoe's Chin -- DAVID, while I appreciate your inclusion of a comparison of Roscoe White's chin to that of the BYP, it does the comparison a marginal disservice in that the photo you include is of an older White whose chin has rounded out a bit over time.
If we use the image on the right below, it becomes a little more convincing:
[ATTACH=CONFIG]5645[/ATTACH]
(taken from: http://jfkplayersandwitnesses.wordpress....coe-white/)
c. Roscoe's Arm Bump -- apparently he had a forearm wound that healed improperly ...
if it can be shown that this claim is true, and that what we are seeing in the below photo is evidence of that, and not simply a process at the end of the ulna bone, it becomes pretty damn hard to refute ...
[ATTACH=CONFIG]5644[/ATTACH]
(taken from: http://harveyandlee.net/Guns/Guns.html)
d. Paranoia, This Board, Self-Contradicting Trolls -- I would like to make note of the fact that while I have received an rather large dose of hate for simply trying to bring up items for discussion, those responsible for hurling insults and allegations against me have made one hell of a convoluted mess of claims. If I have this right, the reason I should not be discussing Roscoe White on this forum is:
1. It was already discussed, and I should have been here 3 years ago
2. It was debunked pretty thoroughly (actually only various claims of his son have been debunked)
3. People have been murdered and threatened for looking in to this already.
4. It is irrelevant to the case, on the whole.
I'm truly sorry if I'm the first person to have to point this out, but claims 2 and 3 are WILDLY in contradiction with each other.
So I should stop discussing this aspect of the case because people have already been murdered and silenced for investigating a hoax?
Huh?
Also, point 4 is just plain obnoxious.
Almost every aspect of the kennedy assassination that can be discussed is a triviality in some regard. I am not going to walk in to a zapruder frame \ hoax or bullet trajectory or brain fragment thread and start screaming "you are an asshole and an agent provocateur leading us down dead ends for discussing this!" in your thread of choice. Why come over here and do it to me?
I happen to find it interesting and down right puzzling that this man, Roscoe White, is on a roll of Lee Harvey Oswald's marine era film, ends up working in the DPD just two months before the assassination, has a jaw that looks much like the BYP, possibly a wrist wound to match as well, and low-and-behold his son comes out and says his diary (which allegedly went missing, mind you) claims he admitted it.
I'm sorry if that makes me a spook, a kook, or a douche.