The Magic Tonsillectomy or Armstrong's Voodoo Science?

[Greg R Parker]

Show me where Philben listed a tonsillectomy anywhere.

As for the evisceration, Albert, all in good time. Patience.

I think it would behoove a practicer of the level of research you pretend to explain why a Tonsillectomy by Dr Philben on Lee Harvey Oswald was claimed in the 1945 Insurance application and by whom?


Anyone else notice Parker running from the question of what Philben would have done if a patient he claimed to do a Tonsillectomy on had a severe tonsil problem later on? Mr Parker seems to not be willing to give an honest answer if Philben would risk the severe penalties and repercussions for that.


This is why I find Mr Parker disingenuous at best and question his motives. He doesn't practice the objectivity he berates others over.


David: Why not have Parker call the Grove Medical Center pharmacist and put his theory to him. In fact why don't you do a conference call and record it. Also, ask the pharmacist if there's any other sources that could confirm Dr Philben's performance of Tonsillectomies? This is very interesting.


.

Sorry Albert, I have been apparently been giving you too much credit for being able to think for yourself, so I will spell it out for you.

There are two possible scenarios that may address your concerns.

1. Philben never claimed to Marguerite that he was performing a tonsillectomy. She made that assumption herself and was not present to see the procedure (which would have consisted of bone and muscle manipulation).

2. Philben did claim he was performing a tonsillectomy. Any future issues over tonsillitis would be addressed by merely saying "they can and do grow back". I think option one is the more likely.