28-06-2015, 02:13 AM
(This post was last modified: 28-06-2015, 03:59 PM by Jim DiEugenio.)
Cliff:
I made no comment about what I personally believed. I was conveying what an author wrote and showed he was related in that to two other writers. This is supposed to be what criticism is all about. You try and show where an author fits in by drawing comparisons.
Why you then have to say this about me:
So I take it you are in the camp of those for whom the physical evidence in the case doesn't exist.
I don't get it at all. If I described a book by the late Harry Livingstone and said something about his belief in Z film alteration, and compared what he said to say Costella or Lifton, would you then say the above about me?
Probably not. Right?
People can believe what they wish about what Horne, and Ryan and Souza describe. I provided a link so they can look at the evidence without it being censored in advance. Which is what Ida Dox and Baden did.
I made no comment about what I personally believed. I was conveying what an author wrote and showed he was related in that to two other writers. This is supposed to be what criticism is all about. You try and show where an author fits in by drawing comparisons.
Why you then have to say this about me:
So I take it you are in the camp of those for whom the physical evidence in the case doesn't exist.
I don't get it at all. If I described a book by the late Harry Livingstone and said something about his belief in Z film alteration, and compared what he said to say Costella or Lifton, would you then say the above about me?
Probably not. Right?
People can believe what they wish about what Horne, and Ryan and Souza describe. I provided a link so they can look at the evidence without it being censored in advance. Which is what Ida Dox and Baden did.