DiEugenio rips Bill O a new one

[Jim DiEugenio]

Well Gordon, you got it.

Plus Martin.

And hopefully Lee and Greg.

[Phil Dragoo]

[ATTACH=CONFIG]4838[/ATTACH]

[Jan Klimkowski]

Phil - excellent graphic.

Don't Look Now...

:cleanears:

[Albert Doyle]

I hear Lifton is forming the fair play for Ruth Paine Society.

[Magda Hassan]

I hear Lifton is forming the fair play for Ruth Paine Society.

:pointlaugh:

[Jim DiEugenio]

Wrong.

Its the Fair Play for Ruth Paine and Priscilla Johnson Committee.

Ray Carroll is the only member. Besides Lifton, of course.

[Dawn Meredith]

Wrong.

Its the Fair Play for Ruth Paine and Priscilla Johnson Committee.

Ray Carroll is the only member. Besides Lifton, of course.

Exactly what I was thinking.
Makes one wonder why they are so valued over there.
I mean it's not like you were saying something NEW Jim. Re PJM.
So one has to question just why Carroll and Lifton are so deferential to her.
We can draw our own conclusions.

Dawn

[Jan Klimkowski]

Wrong.

Its the Fair Play for Ruth Paine and Priscilla Johnson Committee.

Ray Carroll is the only member. Besides Lifton, of course.

Exactly what I was thinking.
Makes one wonder why they are so valued over there.
I mean it's not like you were saying something NEW Jim. Re PJM.
So one has to question just why Carroll and Lifton are so deferential to her.
We can draw our own conclusions.

Dawn

As Phil Dragoo so resonantly observed:

[Dawn Meredith]

Wrong.

Its the Fair Play for Ruth Paine and Priscilla Johnson Committee.

Ray Carroll is the only member. Besides Lifton, of course.

Exactly what I was thinking.
Makes one wonder why they are so valued over there.
I mean it's not like you were saying something NEW Jim. Re PJM.
So one has to question just why Carroll and Lifton are so deferential to her.
We can draw our own conclusions.

Dawn

As Phil Dragoo so resonantly observed:

Yes, Phil never misses.

[Jim DiEugenio]

I agree Dawn.

I mean, the stuff about PJM is ancient. The only new stuff is what Tom Scully put out there. Which I thought was really interesting. ANd Lifton couldn't handle it.

I mean, I could not really comprehend that stuff about a legend. I mean he was really trying to say that somehow PJM wrote what she wrote because of what Oswald presented himself as. And somehow this was no different than what Aline Mosby or the other journalists in Russia did.

I mean, really.

First, It was McVickar who gave her the signal to go up and interview Oswald. Second, it was this interview which was the longest interview Oswald gave an American journalist by far. Newman says it went on for hours. And we know who she worked for, right, NANA.

Now, prior to the assassination, she is classified as a witting collaborator.

THen she reissues her story on the day of the assassination with a much more sinister spin to it.

Then, somehow, she ends up on Marina's doorstep, in August when the WC is winding down. And she helps her find evidence no one had before about Oswald being in Mexico. Wesley Liebeler hit the roof over this by the way.

She then ties up Marina for like 14 years with a book contract. And Tom really nailed her phony excuses about that for the HSCA. But her godawful book finally comes out when interest about Oswald is now teeming about again during the last year of the HSCA. And it comes out with another CIA backed book, Legend, to recertify Oswald as the sociopathic loner again.

And that is all just a coincidence?

Its PJM's books of course that every WC sycophant follows: Posner, Davison, Bugliosi.

The proof of what a put up job Marina and Lee is? Read what she writes about Oswald in New Orleans.